---
id: "20261116-0229-outside-arxiv261117906-indefinite-causal"
title: "Indefinite causal order with definite Bohmian trajectories for the quantum switch (arXiv:2611.17906)"
type: "capture"
status: "promoted"
promoted_to: ["30-notes/claim-drezet-2026-quantum-switch-ico-dissolves-at-bohmian-trajectory-level.md","30-notes/claim-drezet-2026-device-independent-ico-certification-undermined-within-bohmian-mechanics.md","30-notes/claim-drezet-stock-2021-found-1951-bohm-manuscript-in-de-broglie-archive-primitive-draft-of-1952-papers.md","30-notes/claim-drezet-stock-2021-chronology-bohm-reached-causal-interpretation-unaware-of-de-broglie-priority.md"]
not_promoted: ["Entity candidates — created hubs for Louis de Broglie, Aurélien Drezet, Wolfgang Pauli; appended dated lines to existing entity-david-bohm, entity-john-bell, entity-niels-bohr. NOT created: Werner Heisenberg (background comparison figure only, no claim rests on him), Benjamin Stock (co-author of one cited paper only — mention per the 2026-10-01 co-authorship ruling), Giulio Chiribella (quantum-switch originator, further-leads only — flagged [entity] as possibly owed), Brukner/Oreshkov/Costa (process-matrix originators, further-leads only), indefinite causal order / quantum switch / de Broglie–Bohm theory (concept candidates — carried as tags and inline links, not minted as hubs this session).","Further leads — none promoted to claim-notes: Greenberger–Yasin duality-inequality quantification of ICO; Chiribella et al. quantum-switch primary (not fetched); the Baumeler–Feix–Wolf 'Lugano process' open problem for dBB; the recent 'delocalised in time' causal-inequality dispute the author judges unresolved; the promised manuscript scan and the Bohm–Schatzman letter / Bohm–Wilkins 1980 interview (routed instead into question-verify-drezet-stock-2021-bohm-manuscript-and-priority-chronology). These are leads/open problems, not standalone atomic claims."]
origin: "batch"
writer_model: "claude-sonnet-5"
date_created: "2026-11-16T00:00:00.000Z"
provenance: "batch run 2026-11-16"
derived_from: []
tags: ["quantum-foundations","de-broglie-bohm","bohmian-mechanics","indefinite-causal-order","quantum-switch","philosophy-of-physics","history-of-physics"]
source_url: "https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.17906"
source_sha: "b00577ede69b7cdf61776c7caf1c870dbe9fe25b8f21ee7b01fcdb9060a28f5e"
source_author: "Aurélien Drezet"
source_date: "2026-11-13T00:00:00.000Z"
source_title: "Indefinite causal order with definite Bohmian trajectories for the quantum switch"
source_venue: "arXiv (quant-ph; cross-listed physics.hist-ph)"
source_tier: 1
seek_code_commit: "d40ee39"
---


Capture from a fresh external surface (outside-vault topic, 2026-11-16). The paper is a single-author, unrefereed arXiv preprint (submitted 13 Nov 2026, v1 only) by Aurélien Drezet (Institut Néel, CNRS/Univ. Grenoble Alpes), cross-listed quant-ph / physics.hist-ph. It argues that the "quantum switch" (QS) — the paradigmatic experimental demonstration of indefinite causal order (ICO) — admits a fully deterministic de Broglie–Bohm (dBB) description in which particles always follow a single, well-defined trajectory and causal order; ICO, on this reading, is a property of the guiding wave function alone, analogous to wave–particle duality, not a fact about particle histories.

Both the abstract page (archived, sha above) and the full PDF (extracted via `extract_pdf`, sha `9e43c04f63195ef7f2a7110fefb9e14c7207ee335842ff6361adc8bf4117ba1f`, method `pdftotext`, `tls: verified`, 35 pages) were read directly. No recognition signals fired on either fetch — see Safety flags below.

Following a genuine hook from the paper's introduction (its citation [15], the author's own earlier work), a second primary source was also fetched and read in full: Drezet & Stock, "A causal and continuous interpretation of the quantum theory: About an original manuscript by David Bohm sent to Louis de Broglie in 1951" (arXiv:2103.00576, submitted 28 Feb 2021, physics.hist-ph). This connects to nothing currently in the vault but is independently checkable and historically load-bearing, per the topic's instruction to follow what hooks even off-vault.

> [!note] Seek's commentary:
> Two of the four claims below (the paper's two headline results) rest entirely on this one five-day-old, single-author, unrefereed preprint. Per the sources.md single-source concentration cap, that leaves room for only one more claim-note from this specific document before independent corroboration is required — worth flagging at promotion. The other two claims rest on the separate, independent 2021 Drezet & Stock preprint, which is its own single-source count.

## Claim: The paper's central result is that the quantum switch admits no genuine indefinite causal order at the level of Bohmian trajectories — particles always follow one well-defined causal history, with ICO arising only in the guiding wave function

**Claim type:** technical-mechanism (the paper's own stated main result).
**Source:** same as frontmatter (Tier 1 — primary, author's own arXiv preprint).
**source_quote:** "Ultimately, our main result is that, similar to the elusive wave-particle duality [2, 6], there is fundamentally no ICO in dBB at the trajectory level. Like any interference effect, ICOs are associated with the guiding wave function, but particles always follow a unique and well-defined history [13, 14, 16]."
**source_quote_2:** "we have shown that causality is not, in fact, undermined by quantum mechanics once it is read through dBB. Contrary to operationalist rhetoric, a Bohmian reading of ICO remains always possible: the phenomenon admits a description in terms of well-defined trajectories unfolding according to well-defined causal orders."
**source_url:** https://arxiv.org/pdf/2611.17906 · **source_sha:** 9e43c04f63195ef7f2a7110fefb9e14c7207ee335842ff6361adc8bf4117ba1f

The paper builds this result by constructing explicit [[de Broglie–Bohm trajectories]] (via the minimal Bohmian guidance equation, omitting the spin-curl term, following Bohm, Schiller, Tiomno and [[John Bell|Bell]]) for a non-relativistic electron passing through an "unfolded" Mach–Zehnder interferometer standing in for the photonic quantum-switch setup of Procopio et al. The argument is explicitly framed as a rhetorical parallel to wave–particle duality: just as Bohr and Heisenberg treated interference as evidence against classical particle trajectories, and dBB theory shows trajectories survive unscathed, the paper argues ICO is a second instance of the same pattern.

## Claim: The paper argues that device-independent certification of ICO (via violation of a causal inequality under the "DRF" axioms — Definite causal order, Relativistic causality, Free interventions) is undermined within dBB theory, because dBB reproduces the same inequality violations while retaining well-defined trajectories and causal order, drawing on the theory's inherent nonlocality

**Claim type:** technical-mechanism (the paper's second headline argument).
**Source:** same as frontmatter (Tier 1).
**source_quote:** "The latter reproduces exactly the predictions of quantum mechanics, including the maximal violations of the VBC inequality, without altering in any way the notions of trajectories and of a perfectly well-defined causal order. Since dBB theory can account for all these results, the plausibility of the proposed "device-independent certification" of ICO becomes questionable, especially as its underlying principles stand in tension with quantum nonlocality, already established by Bell's theorem."
**source_url:** https://arxiv.org/pdf/2611.17906 · **source_sha:** 9e43c04f63195ef7f2a7110fefb9e14c7207ee335842ff6361adc8bf4117ba1f

The paper draws an explicit contrast with [[John Bell|Bell's theorem]]: Bell's nonlocality is empirically settled (loopholes aside) and licenses real applications like quantum key distribution, whereas the DRF axioms underlying device-independent ICO certification are, per the paper, "neither necessary nor part of dBB theory" — so a violation of the causal inequality (ref. [61] in the paper, a recent no-go-theorem result) does not, on a Bohmian reading, certify an actual indefinite causal order.

## Claim: Drezet & Stock (2021) report discovering, in the Louis de Broglie archive at the French Academy of Sciences, a previously unanalyzed, undated manuscript by David Bohm — titled "A causal and continuous interpretation of the quantum theory" and sent to de Broglie in 1951 — which they argue is a primitive draft of the two 1952 Physical Review papers that are usually credited with founding Bohmian mechanics

**Claim type:** historical (an archival-priority claim — surprising and load-bearing, so held to Tier 1–2 rather than the lower floor normally allowed for uncontested history).
**Source:** Drezet, A.; Stock, B., "A causal and continuous interpretation of the quantum theory: About an original manuscript by David Bohm sent to Louis de Broglie in 1951," arXiv:2103.00576 (Tier 1 — primary, authors' own arXiv preprint; this is also cited as ref. [15] inside arXiv:2611.17906, the capture's main source).
**source_quote:** "This text (referred here as ACCIQT) was found by us in the Archive Louis de Broglie at the French Academy of Science and has gone unnoticed until now [1]. From its content we believe this short text to be a primitive version of the two famous articles 'A suggested interpretation of the quantum theory in terms of hidden variables. I and II' submitted together to the Physical Review the 5th of July 1951 and published the 15th of January 1952 in the same volume [2, 3]."
**source_url:** https://arxiv.org/pdf/2103.00576 · **source_sha:** 47d664ab9ce53fd83a5bb979689dce40e26be652ce8f26d36be68aed1c0cefb3

The manuscript (dubbed "ACCIQT" by Drezet & Stock) is itself reproduced in full in their paper's Section II, under a David Bohm byline giving his then-affiliation as the Faculdade de Filosofia, Ciencias e Letras, Universidade de São Paulo. It presents the quantum potential, the guiding equation, and a response to von Neumann's no-hidden-variables proof, but — per Drezet & Stock's own chronology section — only for the single-particle case, which they say is narrower than the two-particle, full measurement-theory treatment in the published 1952 papers.

## Claim: Drezet & Stock's chronology holds that Bohm initially developed his causal interpretation without knowing of Louis de Broglie's 1927 pilot-wave proposal, and only learned of de Broglie's priority after Pauli and de Broglie both wrote to him in 1951 citing it

**Claim type:** historical (biographical/priority claim; held to Tier 1–2 given it bears on priority).
**Source:** Drezet, A.; Stock, B., arXiv:2103.00576 (Tier 1).
**source_quote:** "'Finally, I decided for a causal interpretation within few weeks, I hit upon the idea which I published not knowing about de Broglie's work until later'"
**source_quote_2:** "'It was old nonsense that de Broglie had done in 1927. They'd had the Solvay Congress there and that he had demolished de Broglie there'"
**source_url:** https://arxiv.org/pdf/2103.00576 · **source_sha:** 47d664ab9ce53fd83a5bb979689dce40e26be652ce8f26d36be68aed1c0cefb3

The first quote is Drezet & Stock's citation of a Bohm letter to astrophysicist Évry Schatzman; the second is their citation of Wolfgang Pauli's reported reaction (via a 1980 Bohm interview with Maurice Wilkins) on first hearing Bohm's causal-interpretation draft, dismissing it as a repeat of [[Louis de Broglie]]'s already-"demolished" 1927 proposal. Drezet & Stock's chronology also notes that part of the Bohm–de Broglie–Pauli correspondence was lost, probably during Bohm's 1951 exile to São Paulo amid persecution by the US House Un-American Activities Committee (HUAC) — recorded here as context, not independently verified against a third source.

## Further leads

- The paper quantifies ICO in the quantum switch via the Greenberger–Yasin duality inequality (visibility² + distinguishability² ≤ 1) rather than the more standard causal-witness/process-matrix approach of Oreshkov, Costa & Brukner (2012) — worth a closer technical read if this vault ever builds out a [[process matrix formalism]] concept note.
- The quantum switch itself is attributed in the paper to Chiribella et al. (ref. [34]), described as "a higher-order quantum operation in which the order of two quantum channels... is placed in a coherent superposition controlled by a quantum control qubit" — the primary Chiribella paper itself was not independently fetched this session.
- The paper's conclusion flags the "Lugano process" of Baumeler, Feix & Wolf (ref. [128]) — a classical, logically consistent causal loop that violates a causal inequality without an agreed spacetime interpretation — as an open problem for dBB theory, unresolved in the paper itself.
- The paper also flags recent claims (refs. [129],[65]) that systems "delocalised in time" can violate causal inequalities in a way the author says appears to conflict with dBB theory and that he judges "has not yet reached sufficient maturity to be resolved unambiguously" — a live, unsettled dispute worth tracking.
- Drezet & Stock's 2021 paper (arXiv:2103.00576) states a PDF scan of the original Bohm manuscript "will be available" (page not located/confirmed this session) — the manuscript's physical holding institution is the Archive Louis de Broglie at the French Academy of Sciences; a scan, if it exists, would be a stronger primary than the 2021 paper's reproduction.
- A Bohm letter to Wolfgang Pauli, and a Bohm interview with Maurice Wilkins (1980), are both cited by Drezet & Stock as sources for the priority-dispute quotes above but were not independently located or read this session — both would be needed to escalate claim 4 above beyond a single secondary-chain source.

## Entity candidates

- Niels Bohr — person — along with Heisenberg, the explicitly named foundational figure whose operationalist/complementarity account of causality the 2026 paper frames its entire argument against (quoted directly from the 1927 Como lecture); flagged first per the instruction to catch the older figure a comparison claim rests on, not just the paper's own author.
- Werner Heisenberg — person — co-architect, with Bohr, of the Copenhagen view of causality that the paper's rhetorical structure (and its wave-particle-duality analogy) is built to rebut; quoted directly from his 1927 uncertainty-principle paper.
- Louis de Broglie — person — originator (1923–27) of the pilot-wave/matter-wave theory that both papers' entire framework rests on; the priority figure behind the 1951 manuscript episode in claim 4; his own archive is where the Bohm manuscript was found.
- David Bohm — person — author of the 1952 papers that founded what is now called de Broglie–Bohm theory, and author of the newly surfaced 1951 manuscript (ACCIQT) analyzed in claim 3; his HUAC-driven 1951 exile to São Paulo is cited as context for a lost portion of the historical correspondence.
- Aurélien Drezet — person — sole author of the 2026 paper (arXiv:2611.17906) and co-author of the 2021 Bohm-manuscript paper; physicist at Institut Néel, CNRS/Univ. Grenoble Alpes.
- Benjamin Stock — person — co-author of the 2021 Bohm-manuscript paper (arXiv:2103.00576); affiliation given as an individual address in Arcisses, France rather than an institution.
- John Bell — person — [[entity-john-bell]] already exists in the vault; his theorem and his argument for retaining the spin-curl-free minimal guidance law are both invoked directly in the 2026 paper, and his theorem anchors the paper's device-independent-certification argument (claim 2).
- Giulio Chiribella — person — credited in the 2026 paper as the originator of the quantum switch construction (with D'Ariano and Perinotti); [[entity-giacomo-mauro-dariano]] already exists in the vault as a frequent collaborator, suggesting a possible link if a Chiribella entity is created.
- Časlav Brukner / Ognyan Oreshkov / Fabio Costa — person (group) — originators of the process-matrix formalism and the causal-inequality framework (2012, *Nat. Commun.*) that the 2026 paper engages with throughout.
- Wolfgang Pauli — person — his skeptical 1951 reaction to Bohm's draft, and his role in alerting Bohm to de Broglie's 1927 priority, are both central to the historical episode in claim 4.
- indefinite causal order (ICO) — concept — the central phenomenon both papers (2026 paper's whole topic) are organized around.
- quantum switch (QS) — concept — the paradigmatic experimental/theoretical construction used to probe ICO.
- de Broglie–Bohm theory / Bohmian mechanics — concept — the deterministic hidden-variable completion of quantum mechanics that is the 2026 paper's interpretive lens throughout.

## Safety flags

None. The arXiv abstract page (fetched first via a web-fetch subagent, then independently archived) and both full PDFs (extracted, TLS verified in both cases) read as ordinary physics/history-of-physics paper content throughout — no addressed-to-AI language, override language, claimed authority, tier self-assignment, file-system instructions, credential requests, or urgency framing encountered on any of the three fetches.
