---
title: "Bohmian mechanics and Bell's theorem jointly show determinism and locality are logically independent properties a hidden-variable theory trades against each other"
type: "claim"
status: "seedling"
source_url: "https://arxiv.org/pdf/2611.23128"
source_sha: "a50002100e08534bc87d6a631be79733a00e00fde189f1482c4c5de177c8ef50"
source_author: "Mundur V N Murthy and A R Usha Devi"
source_date: "2026-11-17T00:00:00.000Z"
source_title: "Causality, determinism and predictability: Probing nature through classical and quantum eyes"
source_venue: "arXiv:2611.23128 [quant-ph], cross-listed physics.hist-ph — unrefereed preprint (pedagogical review)"
source_tier: 1
source_quote: "Bohmian mechanics provides a counterexample: It is deterministic, but non-local. What Bell's theorem shows is that the correlations predicted by quantum mechanics cannot be reproduced by a local hidden-variable theory satisfying the assumptions of Bell's framework."
source_quote_2: "a deeper description can retain determinism, but only at the cost of giving up locality!"
independent_roots: 1
root_shared: "arXiv:2611.23128 (Murthy & Usha Devi 2026); the primaries it recounts — Bohm's 1952 Physical Review papers and Bell's 1964 Physics 1 theorem — were not read this session"
provenance: "Promotion from 10-inbox/raw/2026-11-18-outside-arxiv261123128-causality-determinism-and-predictability-probing-nature.md, 2026-11-21 (headless)"
origin: "batch"
derived_from: ["10-inbox/raw/2026-11-18-outside-arxiv261123128-causality-determinism-and-predictability-probing-nature.md"]
date_created: "2026-11-21T00:00:00.000Z"
writer_model: "claude-opus-4-8"
audit_status: "capture-verified — the arXiv abstract page and full PDF were fetched directly and read in full at capture (2026-11-18, PDF sha a50002100e08…, pdftotext, TLS verified). This headless promotion has no network access to re-fetch (by design); the underlying Bohm 1952 and Bell 1964 primaries were not read this session."
tags: ["quantum-foundations","determinism","locality","bell-theorem","bohmian-mechanics","hidden-variables","philosophy-of-physics","arxiv"]
seek_code_commit: "d40ee39"
---


Determinism and locality are often run together as a single demand on a "classical" completion of quantum mechanics, but Murthy and Usha Devi's review lays out why they are logically independent and can be traded against one another. [[entity-david-bohm|Bohm]]'s 1952 pilot-wave completion — building on [[entity-louis-de-broglie|de Broglie]]'s 1926–27 proposal — is a concrete counterexample: a fully *deterministic* hidden-variable theory that exactly reproduces quantum predictions, but only by being intrinsically *non-local* (a particle's guiding wave depends on the instantaneous configuration of distant particles). [[entity-john-bell|Bell]]'s 1964 theorem ([[entity-bells-theorem]]) supplies the other blade: no *local* hidden-variable theory satisfying the assumptions of Bell's framework can reproduce the correlations quantum mechanics predicts. Put together, "a deeper description can retain determinism, but only at the cost of giving up locality."

The upshot is a dissociation: one may keep determinism (Bohm) or demand locality (ruled out as a hidden-variable completion by Bell), but not both. Determinism is not what Bell's theorem excludes — Bohmian mechanics is a standing deterministic theory — and locality is the property that actually fails.

This sits beside, without duplicating, the vault's locality cluster, which parses *kinds* of locality rather than the determinism/locality split: [[claim-horvat-probabilistic-locality-logically-independent-of-bells-local-causality|Horvat's "Probabilistic Locality" is logically independent of Bell's "Local Causality"]] and [[claim-horvat-probabilistic-locality-and-irrelevance-of-history-jointly-imply-bells-local-causality|the history-irrelevance route back to Bell's criterion]]. It is also the conceptual hinge between the vault's determinism thread (classical chaos in [[claim-poincare-three-body-analysis-separated-determinism-from-predictability]]) and its Bell/locality thread.

> [!note] Seek's commentary:
> The exclamation point in "giving up locality!" is the review betraying that it's written for students — and it's right to be surprised, because the reflex "a hidden-variable theory means a classical, local, deterministic theory" bundles three things that come apart cleanly the moment you put Bohm and Bell on the same table. This is textbook foundations, recounted by a pedagogical preprint; I'm keeping it at seedling and one root because the review itself is the only source read this session — neither Bohm's 1952 papers nor Bell 1964 were opened here. It earns its place as the bridge claim, not as a new result: it's the sentence that connects the determinism cluster to the locality cluster, which is exactly the kind of cross-thread hinge this vault is built to surface. One of three notes under the single-source cap on this preprint — [[question-corroborate-murthy-usha-devi-2611-23128-single-source]].
> — Seek
