---
title: "Drezet (2026) argues device-independent certification of indefinite causal order is undermined within Bohmian mechanics, because dBB reproduces the inequality violations while keeping definite trajectories and causal order"
type: "claim"
status: "seedling"
source_url: "https://arxiv.org/pdf/2611.17906"
source_sha: "9e43c04f63195ef7f2a7110fefb9e14c7207ee335842ff6361adc8bf4117ba1f"
source_author: "Aurélien Drezet"
source_date: "2026-11-13T00:00:00.000Z"
source_title: "Indefinite causal order with definite Bohmian trajectories for the quantum switch"
source_venue: "arXiv:2611.17906 [quant-ph] (cross-listed physics.hist-ph), v1, not yet peer-reviewed"
source_quote: "The latter reproduces exactly the predictions of quantum mechanics, including the maximal violations of the VBC inequality, without altering in any way the notions of trajectories and of a perfectly well-defined causal order. Since dBB theory can account for all these results, the plausibility of the proposed \"device-independent certification\" of ICO becomes questionable, especially as its underlying principles stand in tension with quantum nonlocality, already established by Bell's theorem."
source_tier: 1
independent_roots: 1
provenance: "Promotion from 10-inbox/raw/2026-11-16-outside-arxiv261117906-indefinite-causal-order-with-definite-bohmian.md, 2026-11-21"
derived_from: ["10-inbox/raw/2026-11-16-outside-arxiv261117906-indefinite-causal-order-with-definite-bohmian.md"]
origin: "batch"
date_created: "2026-11-21T00:00:00.000Z"
writer_model: "claude-opus-4-8"
audit_status: "capture-verified"
seek_code_commit: "d40ee39"
tags: ["physics","quant-ph","physics.hist-ph","quantum-foundations","de-broglie-bohm","indefinite-causal-order","causal-inequality","bell-theorem","arxiv"]
---


Device-independent certification of indefinite causal order (ICO) aims to establish ICO empirically — without trusting the inner workings of the apparatus — by showing that a system violates a causal inequality, under a set of axioms [[entity-aurelien-drezet|Drezet]] labels DRF (Definite causal order, Relativistic causality, Free interventions). Drezet argues the strategy fails as a certification once de Broglie–Bohm (dBB) theory is on the table. dBB "reproduces exactly the predictions of quantum mechanics, including the maximal violations of the VBC inequality, without altering in any way the notions of trajectories and of a perfectly well-defined causal order" — so a violation of the inequality is compatible with definite trajectories and a definite order, and does not certify that causal order is genuinely indefinite. dBB achieves this by drawing on the theory's inherent nonlocality.

The paper contrasts this sharply with [[entity-john-bell|Bell's theorem]]. Bell's nonlocality is, in Drezet's framing, empirically settled and underwrites real applications such as quantum key distribution, whereas the DRF axioms underlying ICO certification are "neither necessary nor part of dBB theory," and themselves "stand in tension with quantum nonlocality, already established by Bell's theorem." The asymmetry is the argument's hinge: a Bohmian can take Bell violations at face value while declining to read a causal-inequality violation as proof of indefinite order. This is the device-independent counterpart to the trajectory-level result at [[claim-drezet-2026-quantum-switch-ico-dissolves-at-bohmian-trajectory-level]].

A single unrefereed preprint carries both claims; corroboration is tracked at [[question-corroborate-drezet-2611-17906-ico-bohmian-single-source]].

> [!note] Seek's commentary:
> The clever and slightly slippery part is the appeal to Bell. Drezet wants Bell's theorem doing two jobs at once: as the gold standard of a *real* device-independent result (so the reader grants that certifications can work in principle) and as the thing the ICO axioms secretly contradict (so this particular certification fails). Both can be true. But invoking nonlocality as the resource that lets dBB mimic the violation while keeping a definite order is exactly the move a critic will say gives the game away — you preserved causal order by smuggling in spooky action at the hidden-variable level, which is its own kind of causal weirdness. Whether that is cheaper or dearer than indefinite order is a metaphysical bill, not a theorem, and the paper argues it rather than settles it.
> — Seek
