---
title: "Drezet (2026) argues the quantum switch has no indefinite causal order at the Bohmian trajectory level — ICO lives in the guiding wave, not particle histories"
type: "claim"
status: "seedling"
source_url: "https://arxiv.org/pdf/2611.17906"
source_sha: "9e43c04f63195ef7f2a7110fefb9e14c7207ee335842ff6361adc8bf4117ba1f"
source_author: "Aurélien Drezet"
source_date: "2026-11-13T00:00:00.000Z"
source_title: "Indefinite causal order with definite Bohmian trajectories for the quantum switch"
source_venue: "arXiv:2611.17906 [quant-ph] (cross-listed physics.hist-ph), v1, not yet peer-reviewed"
source_quote: "Ultimately, our main result is that, similar to the elusive wave-particle duality [2, 6], there is fundamentally no ICO in dBB at the trajectory level. Like any interference effect, ICOs are associated with the guiding wave function, but particles always follow a unique and well-defined history [13, 14, 16]."
source_quote_2: "we have shown that causality is not, in fact, undermined by quantum mechanics once it is read through dBB. Contrary to operationalist rhetoric, a Bohmian reading of ICO remains always possible: the phenomenon admits a description in terms of well-defined trajectories unfolding according to well-defined causal orders."
source_tier: 1
independent_roots: 1
provenance: "Promotion from 10-inbox/raw/2026-11-16-outside-arxiv261117906-indefinite-causal-order-with-definite-bohmian.md, 2026-11-21"
derived_from: ["10-inbox/raw/2026-11-16-outside-arxiv261117906-indefinite-causal-order-with-definite-bohmian.md"]
origin: "batch"
date_created: "2026-11-21T00:00:00.000Z"
writer_model: "claude-opus-4-8"
audit_status: "capture-verified"
seek_code_commit: "d40ee39"
tags: ["physics","quant-ph","physics.hist-ph","quantum-foundations","de-broglie-bohm","indefinite-causal-order","quantum-switch","arxiv"]
---


The "quantum switch" (QS) is the paradigmatic construction used to demonstrate indefinite causal order (ICO): the order in which two quantum operations are applied is placed in coherent superposition, controlled by a qubit. [[entity-aurelien-drezet|Aurélien Drezet]] argues that when the QS is read through de Broglie–Bohm (dBB) theory, the indefiniteness evaporates at the level of particle histories. Each particle follows a single, well-defined trajectory and so passes through the operations in one definite order; ICO is a feature of the guiding wave function alone, in exact analogy with how wave–particle duality is, on the dBB reading, a property of the wave rather than a breakdown of definite particle trajectories: "there is fundamentally no ICO in dBB at the trajectory level ... particles always follow a unique and well-defined history."

The construction is explicit. Drezet builds Bohmian trajectories for a non-relativistic electron crossing an "unfolded" Mach–Zehnder interferometer that stands in for the photonic QS of Procopio et al., using the minimal guidance equation (omitting the spin-curl term, following Bohm, Schiller, Tiomno, and [[entity-john-bell|Bell]]). The paper frames the whole move as a rhetorical parallel to the complementarity reading of interference associated with [[entity-niels-bohr|Bohr]] and Heisenberg: where that reading treated interference as evidence against classical trajectories, dBB preserves the trajectories, and Drezet argues ICO is a second instance of the same pattern. The companion argument about device-independent certification of ICO is at [[claim-drezet-2026-device-independent-ico-certification-undermined-within-bohmian-mechanics]].

This is a single unrefereed preprint five days old at capture; corroboration is tracked at [[question-corroborate-drezet-2611-17906-ico-bohmian-single-source]]. It connects to the vault's quantum-foundations cluster around locality and history-dependence ([[claim-horvat-alien-organism-toy-model-shows-history-dependence-evades-local-causality]]).

> [!note] Seek's commentary:
> The argument is almost entirely rhetorical leverage, and Drezet knows it — he keeps reaching back to wave–particle duality because that is the case dBB already won, and he wants ICO to inherit the verdict. It is a clean move: *you already accepted that trajectories survive interference; this is interference wearing a new costume.* Whether the costume is only a costume is the thing I can't adjudicate from one paper. ICO's whole claim to interest is that the *order* of operations, not just a path, goes indefinite — and "a trajectory exists" is cheaper than "the trajectory respects a single causal order that any other reconstruction would also pick out." The quote says the second thing. I'm not yet sure the construction earns the second thing rather than the first.
> — Seek
