---
title: "Moore, Smith & Mertens (2026) find the historical Cassini oval cannot serve as an exact Ptolemaic equant, because the ellipse's reflection-principle argument does not generalize to it"
type: "claim"
status: "seedling"
source_url: "https://arxiv.org/pdf/2610.05358"
source_author: "Cristopher Moore, Malcolm Smith, Stephan Mertens"
source_date: "2026-10-04"
source_title: "Astronomia Ova: Kepler's Laws, Ptolemy's Equant, and Legendre's Polynomials"
source_venue: "arXiv (physics.hist-ph / astro-ph.EP), arXiv:2610.05358v1 — unrefereed preprint, §2.4 ('The Cassinoid')"
source_quote: "Unfortunately, this orbit does not fulfill our desire for an equant. The problem is that the reflection principle behind (6) only holds for ellipses, and a curve cannot be both an ellipse and a cassinoid unless it is a circle."
source_quote_2: ". . . a line has been devised to serve as an orbit for the planets. This line is a type of ellipse in which the rectangles [products] formed by the lines [distances] drawn from the planet to both foci are always equal; whereas in ordinary ellipses, it is the sums of the two distances from the foci that are always equal to each other."
source_tier: 1
source_sha: "7b6c7ee28bca3c09a6474998435f56fa3e31addfacdcb6230c70fdc47410d71e"
source_sha_2: "7b6c7ee28bca3c09a6474998435f56fa3e31addfacdcb6230c70fdc47410d71e"
independent_roots: 1
audit_status: "capture-verified — the capturing session (2026-11-18) fetched arXiv:2610.05358's PDF directly via extract_pdf and quote-checked both passages verbatim (sha 7b6c7ee2…); this headless promotion performed no independent re-fetch. This paper is already in the vault as the subject of [[claim-astronomia-ova-orbit-family-satisfies-keplers-second-law-and-exact-equant]], which concerns a different section (the authors' own novel orbit family); this note covers a distinct section (§2.4) discussing the real historical Cassini oval, not previously promoted."
provenance: "Promotion from 10-inbox/raw/2026-11-18-does-any-independent-source-corroborate-descamps-arxiv261121336-force.md, 2026-11-18"
origin: "batch"
derived_from: ["20261118-0210-does-any-independent-source"]
date_created: "2026-11-18T00:00:00.000Z"
writer_model: "claude-sonnet-5"
tags: ["physics","history-of-science","astronomy","kepler","ptolemy","cassini","equant","legendre-polynomials","corroboration","single-source-cap","outside"]
seek_code_commit: "d40ee39"
quote_sweep: "PASS 2026-11-19 — source_quote verbatim (normalized) in the capture-time archive (sha256 7b6c7ee28bca…), same-night model-free sweep"
verified_verbatim: "2026-11-19 — source_quote matched verbatim (normalized) against a direct fetch of source_url by seek_verify (no model involved)"
---


Moore, Smith & Mertens's "Astronomia Ova" (arXiv:2610.05358, Oct. 2026) — already in the vault for constructing a *novel* orbit family satisfying both Kepler's second law and an exact [[entity-ptolemys-equant|equant]] ([[claim-astronomia-ova-orbit-family-satisfies-keplers-second-law-and-exact-equant]]) — devotes §2.4 to the actual historical [[entity-cassini-oval|Cassini oval]] by name, quoting [[entity-giovanni-domenico-cassini|Cassini]]'s own 1693 description of the curve ("a type of ellipse in which the rectangles formed by the lines drawn from the planet to both foci are always equal") and noting it was "also discussed by his son Jacques." They test the oval directly against the equant question and report failure: "Unfortunately, this orbit does not fulfill our desire for an equant. The problem is that the reflection principle behind (6) only holds for ellipses, and a curve cannot be both an ellipse and a cassinoid unless it is a circle."

This paper was submitted six weeks before Pascal Descamps's 2026 preprint, from an unrelated research direction (constructing new orbit families), with no citation link either way — a genuinely independent mathematical treatment. It does not corroborate or contradict [[claim-cassini-oval-empty-focus-is-38x-better-equant-than-ellipses-for-the-sun]]: Descamps's claim is that the oval's empty focus is a far better *approximate* equant than the ellipse's own, a weaker bar than the *exact* equant Moore, Smith & Mertens ask about here. The two papers measure different things on the same curve. See [[question-corroborate-descamps-2026-arxiv-2611-21336-single-source-cap]].

> [!note] Seek's commentary:
> Both papers agree the oval is a near-miss and disagree on what kind of near-miss it is — approximately excellent at the weaker test, exactly disqualified from the stronger one — and neither author group knew the other was grading the same curve. That's the useful kind of agreement: not an echo, two independent graders converging on the same transcript. — Seek
