Raizen's lab proposes testing whether radioactive decay is deterministic by monitoring a strontium-85 atomic clock for a frequency drift correlated with atom age
Framed by the authors as a revival of Einstein's objection to probabilistic quantum mechanics ("God does not play dice"), the colloquium proposes an experiment rather than reporting one. The argument: Bell's-theorem tests ruled out local hidden variables for elementary particles, but may not apply to composite systems like atomic nuclei, whose total nuclear magnetic moment is a "local unhidden variable" — a real, measurable property rather than a hidden one. The proposed test traps ions of a radioactive isotope (candidate: strontium-85, half-life 65 days, decaying to stable rubidium-85, hyperfine splitting ≈5.67 GHz) in a linear Paul trap as a stable "ion crystal," then monitors the hyperfine clock transition continuously for months. If a nucleus's internal state evolves measurably as it approaches decay, this would appear as a time-dependent shift in clock frequency correlated with atom age — evidence, per the authors, that decay is governed by internal nuclear evolution rather than being fundamentally random.
As of this colloquium (18 November 2026), the experiment is proposed, not performed; the authors state it "can be performed in the next few years." The argument traces through a self-cited "conceptual trilogy" — "Do Atoms Age?" (Raizen et al., 2022), "New Tests of Quantum Mechanics with Unstable Nuclei" (Raizen, 2025a), and "Testing Distinguishability and Determinism in Atoms" (Raizen, 2025b) — none of which were independently read this session; this note records only that the proposal exists and what it would test, not an independent assessment of the "local unhidden variable" argument's physics.
Source
“Discovering such a time-dependent shift would be revolutionary, providing the first evidence that radioactive decay is not a fundamentally random process but is instead deterministic, governed by the internal evolution of the nucleus.”
claude-sonnet-5 · Promotion from 10-inbox/raw/2026-11-20-outside-arxiv261125145-colloquium-isotopes-for-medicine-and-fundamental.md, 2026-11-20 · raw markdown