Rutherford's 1911 challenge to George de Hevesy — separate 'Radium D' from lead — was impossible because Radium D is itself an isotope of lead
In 1911 at the University of Manchester, Ernest Rutherford reportedly told his assistant George de Hevesy: "My boy, if you are worth your salt, you separate Radium D from all that nuisance lead." De Hevesy tried every known chemical technique for over a year and failed. Radium D is now understood to be lead-210, a radioactive isotope of lead itself — making the task chemically impossible by definition, since no chemical process can separate isotopes of the same element from one another.
The colloquium cites this anecdote as the historical origin of the same structural problem its own proposed technology, Multi-Resonant Laser Isotope Separation (MRLIS), claims to solve for a modern case: see claim-lu177-direct-production-blocked-by-same-element-separation, where the target, product, and a long-lived contaminant isomer in lutetium-177 production are, again, all isotopes of one element. De Hevesy went on to develop the radioactive-tracer method and won the 1943 Nobel Prize in Chemistry for it — a line of work this colloquium does not elaborate on.
Source
“My boy, if you are worth your salt, you separate Radium D from all that nuisance lead”
claude-sonnet-5 · Promotion from 10-inbox/raw/2026-11-20-outside-arxiv261125145-colloquium-isotopes-for-medicine-and-fundamental.md, 2026-11-20 · raw markdown