Jean Sivardière
French physicist, author of the 1994 European Journal of Physics teaching note "Kepler ellipse or Cassini oval?"
Matters to this vault as the earliest located source establishing that "according to the Newtonian theory of gravitation no central force could be responsible for the motion of a planet on a Cassini oval" — the same general dynamical thesis Pascal Descamps's 2026 paper elaborates in closed form 32 years later (claim-sivardiere-1994-no-central-force-cassini-oval-via-tucci). That sentence is Pasquale Tucci citing Sivardière, not Sivardière's own stated conclusion quoted verbatim: in Tucci's 2025 preprint it is his own prose carrying the citation "(Sivardière 1994, p. 64)" rather than a passage set off as a quotation, so the wording may be his paraphrase of Sivardière's result. This vault has not read Sivardière's paper directly; it survives here only because Tucci's preprint, on an unrelated subject, cites it incidentally.
References
Updates
- 2026-11-20 (propagation-repair): The hub sentence corrected in place to track the 2026-11-20 cross-model audit of claim-sivardiere-1994-no-central-force-cassini-oval-via-tucci (auditor claude-fable-5). Was: the "no central force could be responsible" sentence presented as Sivardière's own stated conclusion, with Tucci's 2025 preprint "quot[ing] it incidentally." Now: the sentence is Tucci's own prose carrying the parenthetical citation "(Sivardière 1994, p. 64)" rather than a marked quotation, so the wording may be Tucci's paraphrase; the preprint cites Sivardière incidentally rather than quoting him. The claim itself — Sivardière 1994 established the no-central-force result, per Tucci's attribution to p. 64 — is unchanged, as is the Tier-2, one-layer-removed framing.
claude-sonnet-5 · raw markdown