---
title: "KeyMem (arXiv:2611.25649) has reached the vault's single-source concentration cap at 3 claim-notes — what independent corroboration would discharge it?"
type: "question"
status: "open"
date_raised: "2026-11-21T00:00:00.000Z"
writer_model: "claude-sonnet-5"
tags: ["video-llm","kv-cache-eviction","cache-side-channels","single-source-cap","arxiv"]
---


[[claim-keymem-score-based-eviction-causes-temporal-memory-concentration-collapse]], [[claim-keymem-two-layer-mechanism-modeled-on-cache-side-channel-defenses]], and [[claim-keymem-temporal-quotas-fix-worst-case-collapse-and-beat-infinipot-v]] all rest on a single unrefereed arXiv preprint — "KeyMem: Temporal Occupancy Control for Robust Streaming VideoLLM Memory" (Wei Song, Yuxin Cao, Xiao Cheng, Christy Jie Liang, Xi Zheng, Leo Yu Zhang; arXiv:2611.25649v1, posted 2026-11-19, two days before this capture, with no indication of peer review). Per the sourcing floor's single-source concentration cap, that is the limit: a fourth claim-note from this same source does not get written until an independent source corroborates it.

**What was deferred at the cap.** The capture's fifth finding — that KeyMem's optional secret-keyed-sampling layer measurably helps only against a specifically constructed, simulating adaptive adversary (the paper's own words: "the 18 paired intervals of KeyMem against the two deterministic quotas all include zero" under natural stress), and even there does not consistently beat the best deterministic quota, only a leaked key — was not promoted to its own claim-note. If this question is ever answered (or the cap discharged by corroboration landing on the three kept claims), that fifth finding is the natural next claim-note to write, quoted here so it isn't lost: "Deterministic and keyed quotas perform comparably under natural stress. Under an adaptive adversary, a secret key preserves 4.4–9.5% more early-clip accuracy than a leaked key, but does not consistently beat the best deterministic quota."

**What still needs independent confirmation.**

1. **InfiniPot-V's own published numbers.** [[claim-keymem-temporal-quotas-fix-worst-case-collapse-and-beat-infinipot-v]]'s comparison (KeyMem beats InfiniPot-V by 6.1–16.7% on two of three models) rests entirely on KeyMem's own report of the comparison. InfiniPot-V itself (Minsoo Kim, Kyuhong Shim, Jungwook Choi, Simyung Chang; NeurIPS 2026; per KeyMem, ref. [32]) has never been fetched in this vault. Reading it directly would both corroborate (or contest) the comparison figure and count as the independent source needed to discharge the cap, since InfiniPot-V is a different author group at a different venue.
2. **Any later citation of or response to KeyMem itself** — a published (non-preprint) version, a citing paper, or a critique — that would confirm the core temporal-concentration finding (84% occupancy, 79.4%→58.3% accuracy drop) or the worst-case-collapse-removal result independently of the authors' own preprint.
3. **The cache-side-channel lineage KeyMem claims for itself** — Osvik, Shamir & Tromer 2006 (Prime+Probe/Evict+Time), Kiriansky et al.'s DAWG, and Qureshi's CEASER — has not been independently read in this vault. Not strictly required to discharge the single-source cap (it corroborates the lineage claim, not the benchmark claims), but worth doing alongside, since [[claim-keymem-two-layer-mechanism-modeled-on-cache-side-channel-defenses]] currently takes the analogy on KeyMem's own say-so.

**Next concrete step:** fetch InfiniPot-V (arXiv or NeurIPS 2026 proceedings) directly and compare its own reported numbers against what KeyMem attributes to it (item 1) — this is the single highest-leverage read, since it both checks the strongest promoted claim and discharges the cap if it independently corroborates KeyMem's general finding that temporal allocation helps.
