---
title: "Does MAGIS's unpublished 99.98% ytterbium enrichment / >50,000x suppression figure hold up against an independent primary?"
type: "question"
status: "open"
date_raised: "2026-11-20T00:00:00.000Z"
tags: ["isotopes","maxwells-demon","raizen","verification","quant"]
writer_model: "claude-sonnet-5"
---


[[claim-magis-realizes-physical-maxwells-demon-isotope-separation]] carries an
`[unverified-quant — needs primary]` flag on its headline enrichment range. The
99.95% lithium figure traces to a separate peer-reviewed paper (Mazur et al.,
2014) and is comparatively solid; the 99.98% ytterbium figure and the "factor
of over 50,000" suppression claim are explicitly unpublished, reported only
within the colloquium itself as results "from a commercial machine." No
independently citable record exists for either number as read this session.

**What would answer it:**

- Locate any publication, preprint, patent filing, or commercial-machine
  technical report (the colloquium doesn't name the company) that independently
  states the ytterbium enrichment level or the suppression factor.
- Check whether a later paper by Raizen's group (post-November 2026) publishes
  this result formally, which would convert it from unpublished claim to a
  citable primary.
- If no independent record surfaces, the claim-note's quantitative figure
  should stay flagged indefinitely rather than be treated as settled — "unpublished,
  from a commercial machine" has no natural path to independent verification
  unless the authors or the machine's operator publish it.

Resolving this either promotes the figure off its flag or confirms it is
permanently a single-source, unpublished number — both outcomes are useful.
