---
title: "Does a contemporaneous 1960s document from Ostrovskii's own side corroborate Griewank's \"~1965\" use-date for reverse-mode differentiation?"
type: "question"
status: "open"
date_raised: "2026-11-21T00:00:00.000Z"
tags: ["reverse-mode-ad","ostrowski","griewank","priority","history-of-computation"]
---


## The question

Andreas Griewank's own historical accounts (2012, 2014) credit
[[entity-g-m-ostrovskii|G. M. Ostrovskii]]'s group with discovering and
using reverse-mode differentiation in chemical-process models "some five
years earlier" than [[entity-seppo-linnainmaa|Seppo Linnainmaa]]'s 1970
thesis — i.e., roughly 1965. Their only *published* paper on the subject
(Ostrovskii, Volin & Borisov, "Über die Berechnung von Ableitungen," *Wiss.
Z. Tech. Hochschule für Chemie* 13: 382–384) did not appear until 1971, one
year *after* Linnainmaa's thesis. That 1971 date does not itself contradict
the "five years earlier" framing, because Griewank is explicitly dating
*use*, not *publication* — but the ~1965 use-date has, as of two independent
vault sessions (2026-07-07 and 2026-11-21), never been corroborated against
any document actually from Ostrovskii's own hand. It rests entirely on
Griewank's retrospective account.

This matters because the ~1965 date is load-bearing for
[[claim-reverse-mode-multiple-independent-discovery]]'s framing of Ostrovskii
as the *earliest* of the five-plus named independent discoverers of reverse
mode — if the use-date collapses toward 1971 (or later), Ostrovskii's
position in that list changes from "before Linnainmaa" to "after."

## What would answer it

A contemporaneous 1960s primary document, read directly (Tier 1–2 required
per the historical/priority sourcing floor in `00-meta/specs/sources.md`),
showing the chemical-engineering reverse-mode-style derivative technique in
use. Candidate leads, none read directly by the vault as of 2026-11-21:

- An Ostrovskii & Volin paper reportedly at the "All-Union Conference on
  Chemical Reactors, Novosibirsk, 1965" — surfaced only via an unread
  WebSearch snippet; bibliographic details (exact title, proceedings
  citation) not yet confirmed.
- Fedotov, Volin, Ostrovskii & Slin'ko, "Application of the Maximum
  Principle to Determining the Optimal Conditions of Chemical Processes"
  (1968).
- Ostrovskii & Volin (1969), on the maximum principle for discontinuous
  systems.
- Griewank & Walther, *Principles and Techniques of Algorithmic
  Differentiation*, 2nd ed. (SIAM, 2008) — cited by Griewank 2012 as
  reference [7] for material not in the 2012 paper's own bibliography;
  might carry more detail on Ostrovskii's actual 1960s publications or
  working papers. Not read by the vault.

## Candidate next moves

- Locate and read the 1965 Novosibirsk conference proceedings (or a
  citing secondary that quotes its title/venue precisely enough to chase).
- Read Griewank & Walther 2008 for whatever OVB detail it carries beyond
  the 2012/2014 papers' citation-key-only references.
- If no 1960s document surfaces after a reasonable search, say so plainly
  in [[claim-reverse-mode-multiple-independent-discovery]] rather than
  letting the gap go silent — the claim can stand as "Griewank's
  attribution," which is itself a legitimate (if weaker) status.

## Related
- [[claim-reverse-mode-multiple-independent-discovery]]
- [[entity-g-m-ostrovskii]]
- [[entity-andreas-griewank]]
