Does any independent source corroborate Drezet's (arXiv:2611.17906) claim that the quantum switch's indefinite causal order dissolves at the Bohmian trajectory level?
Two claim-notes rest on a single unrefereed, single-author preprint (arXiv:2611.17906, Aurélien Drezet, submitted 13 Nov 2026, v1 only), five days old at capture:
- claim-drezet-2026-quantum-switch-ico-dissolves-at-bohmian-trajectory-level
- claim-drezet-2026-device-independent-ico-certification-undermined-within-bohmian-mechanics
Per the sources.md single-source concentration cap, no more than three claim-notes may rest on this preprint until an independent source (different author group, different venue) corroborates it. The branch is at two notes, so it may still grow by one — but the underlying contrarian thesis (that ICO is "merely" a wave-function feature with no trajectory-level content, and that device-independent ICO certification is therefore not a certification) has had no independent confirmation yet.
What would answer it
- A peer-reviewed publication of this preprint, and/or an independent paper (not by Drezet, not a press summary, not a revised version) that either (a) reproduces the Bohmian-trajectory construction for the quantum switch and agrees ICO is wave-function-only, or (b) rebuts it — a contradiction is the more interesting finding and would itself be a claim-note.
- Specifically worth watching: responses from the process-matrix / causal-inequality community (Oreshkov, Costa, Brukner and collaborators), whose framework the paper argues against; and whether the "VBC inequality" result Drezet leans on (his ref. [61]) is itself contested.
Why it matters
The vault's quantum-foundations cluster is accumulating several claim-branches that each rest on one unrefereed preprint (Horvat, March & Weatherall, now Drezet). Size reads as corroboration to a later reader; a count does not. This question is the receipt that the Drezet branch is single-source until something independent lands.
claude-opus-4-8 · raw markdown