Baydin et al. 2018 split reverse-mode AD credit between Linnainmaa's first published description and Speelpenning's first automatic implementation
Immediately after crediting Linnainmaa (1970, 1976) as "often cited as the first published description of the reverse mode" (claim-baydin-et-al-2018-hedges-linnainmaa-priority-defers-origin-to-griewank-2012), Baydin, Pearlmutter, Radul & Siskind's 2018 survey draws an explicit line between description and implementation:
"Speelpenning (1980) subsequently introduced reverse mode AD as we know it, in the sense that he gave the first implementation that was actually automatic, accepting a specification of a computational process written in a general-purpose programming language and automatically performing the reverse mode transformation."
The survey's own historical account therefore does not award "origin of modern AD" to one person. It splits the credit at least three ways across its §3.3 narrative: Werbos for formalizing the method with topologically-sorted discrete-time variables, Linnainmaa for the first published description, and Speelpenning for the first working automatic system.
This is a distinct finding from the vault's existing Speelpenning thread, which established — via a direct read of Speelpenning's own 1980 thesis and its reference list — that his thesis does not cite Linnainmaa at all (claim-speelpenning-1980-does-not-cite-linnainmaa). That earlier note is about Speelpenning's own citation practice; this one is about how a later, third-party, field-standard survey retrospectively ranks the two men's contributions along a description/implementation axis that Speelpenning's own thesis never drew. The two findings corroborate rather than duplicate one another: both place Speelpenning's contribution downstream of, and distinct from, Linnainmaa's — one from the primary document's silence, the other from a later survey's explicit framing.
Vault connections
Companion to claim-baydin-et-al-2018-hedges-linnainmaa-priority-defers-origin-to-griewank-2012 (same section, same source, the origin-adjudication half of this capture's finding) and claim-speelpenning-1980-does-not-cite-linnainmaa (the citation-silence half, from Speelpenning's own primary text).
Source
“Speelpenning (1980) subsequently introduced reverse mode AD as we know it, in the sense that he gave the first implementation that was actually automatic, accepting a specification of a computational process written in a general-purpose programming language and automatically performing the reverse mode transformation.”
claude-sonnet-5 · Promotion from 10-inbox/raw/2026-11-21-what-does-baydin-et-al-2018-arxiv-150205767.md, 2026-11-21 · raw markdown