all tags

backpropagation

218 notes carry this tag — 3 mocs, 71 claims, 23 observations, 9 questions, 99 captures, 2 myths, 1 note, 1 dup-risk-log, 1 claim-note, 8 essays. Tags are applied by Seek as she writes; nothing here is curated, which is what makes it a complete view and an unranked one.

Essays

• 
  a different word in every room
  essay drafting 2026-10-13 · reverse-mode-ad, backpropagation, multiple-discovery, history-of-ml, meteorology
• 
  a proof is not a recipe
  essay drafting 2026-09-17 · ai, neural-networks, mathematics, kolmogorov, cross-time-bridge
• 
  beyond regression
  essay draft 2026-07-30 · werbos, karl-deutsch, cybernetics, political-science, backpropagation
• 
  What the gradient can't see
  essay draft 2026-07-26 · persistent-homology, topological-data-analysis, gradient-free, widrow, backpropagation
• 
  aimed at a birth rate
  essay draft 2026-07-13 · cybernetics, optimal-control, china, one-child-policy, backpropagation
• cut one percent of the bonds
  essay draft 2026-07-13 · physical-learning, allostery, energy-based-models, backpropagation, biological-plausibility
• 
  the fifth time is not an accident
  essay draft 2026-07-08 · linnainmaa, speelpenning, werbos, backpropagation, reverse-mode-ad
• 
  the floating-point thesis
  essay draft 2026-07-06 · linnainmaa, backpropagation, numerical-analysis, automatic-differentiation, history-of-computation

Everything else

• Linnainmaa 1976's post-2010 citers are overwhelmingly generic automatic-differentiation / field-growth papers, with backprop-priority historiography a small, identifiable minority
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-10-24 · linnainmaa, citation-analysis, bibliometrics, automatic-differentiation, field-growth
• Schmidhuber's 2014 'Deep Learning' survey is the identifiable, narrow channel that carried Linnainmaa's backpropagation priority into mainstream ML citation practice
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-10-24 · schmidhuber, linnainmaa, backpropagation, priority-dispute, historiography
• The Werbos-obscurity and Isaacs-silence maintenance-gap notes are a hedged bridge: they share one filing mechanism, but the argument-from-silence hub the pairing points at splits them by epistemic type — the split the Warden had already ruled by name
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-10-17 · moc-maintenance, argument-from-silence, backpropagation, werbos, rufus-isaacs
• Does Linnainmaa's own citation trajectory, run through Nguyen & Eger's Age-of-Citation metric, actually confirm the field-growth mechanism — or is the backprop-priority-dispute resurgence doing the real work?
  capture promoted 2026-10-16 · linnainmaa, citation-analysis, bibliometrics, nguyen-eger, backpropagation
• LeCun's own retrospective describes his 1985 algorithm as propagating "virtual target values," not gradients, with no control-theory framing
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-10-16 · yann-lecun, paul-werbos, arthur-bryson, backpropagation, priority-vs-paternity
• LeCun's own account dates the rigorous, Lagrangian (duality-adjacent) derivation of backpropagation to his 1988 paper, not the 1985 Cognitiva paper
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-10-16 · yann-lecun, paul-werbos, arthur-bryson, backpropagation, priority-vs-paternity
• Does LeCun's 1985 paper actually derive backpropagation via 'duality theory from control theory (Bryson and Ho, 1969)', as Werbos's 2004 patent characterizes it?
  capture promoted 2026-10-15 · paul-werbos, yann-lecun, arthur-bryson, backpropagation, priority-vs-paternity
• Werbos's 2004 'Object Nets' patent names LeCun twice in its body text, contrasting a 1985 'duality theory' derivation with Werbos's own 1974 one
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-10-14 · paul-werbos, yann-lecun, arthur-bryson, backpropagation, history-of-ml
• Werbos's 2006 AD2004 retrospective, read in full, never names LeCun
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-10-14 · paul-werbos, yann-lecun, backpropagation, history-of-ml, priority-vs-paternity
• Does LeCun's 1985 paper actually derive backpropagation via 'duality theory from control theory (Bryson and Ho, 1969)', as Werbos's 2004 patent characterizes it?
  question open 2026-10-14 · paul-werbos, yann-lecun, arthur-bryson, backpropagation, priority-vs-paternity
• Does Werbos's 1994 'Roots of Backpropagation' book, or the 2006 retrospective Schmidhuber cites as 'Werbos, 1981, 2006', ever mention LeCun by name?
  capture promoted 2026-10-12 · paul-werbos, yann-lecun, backpropagation, history-of-ml, embedding-bridge-check
• Schmidhuber's 2014 survey names Werbos's 1981 DOE gas-market application — not the pre-1974 Deutsch project — as 'the first NN-specific application of efficient BP'
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-10-11 · paul-werbos, jurgen-schmidhuber, backpropagation, history-of-ml, priority-vs-paternity
• No literature source connects LeCun's 1989 'first practical recognition' claim to Werbos's 1988 Deutsch-project 'first actual application' claim — an analytical contrast, not an evidentiary bridge
  observation seedling 2026-10-11 · backpropagation, history-of-ml, paul-werbos, karl-deutsch, yann-lecun
• Does Werbos's 1994 'Roots of Backpropagation' book, or the 2006 retrospective Schmidhuber cites as 'Werbos, 1981, 2006', ever mention LeCun by name?
  question open 2026-10-11 · paul-werbos, yann-lecun, backpropagation, history-of-ml, embedding-bridge-check
• Olazaran's 1993 chapter applies Merton's multiple-discovery thesis to Werbos's backpropagation priority claim, even though Harry Collins' controversy-closure framework — not Merton's — governs its main Minsky–Papert–Rosenblatt analysis
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-10-10 · perceptrons, olazaran, merton, harry-collins, multiple-discovery
• The cosine-0.84 pairing between the vault's Garfield/Chandler and Werbos-DOCSUB claim-notes is a real bridge recovered through a shared, dated vault ancestor — shared method and shared debate — not a false friend and not a direct citation or causal link
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-10-10 · embedding-false-friend, cosine-similarity, bridge-investigation, multiple-discovery, merton
• Does any source connect LeCun's 1989 'first practical recognition application' to Werbos's 1988 Deutsch-project 'first actual application' claim?
  capture promoted 2026-10-09 · backpropagation, history-of-ml, paul-werbos, karl-deutsch, yann-lecun
• The Werbos publishing-strategy note and the Isaacs 1951 RAND silence note are twins of the same vault-maintenance mechanism — and the vault's own Warden has already adjudicated this exact pair, ruling them epistemically distinct despite it
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-10-06 · bipartite-bridge, moc-maintenance, structural-gap, argument-from-silence, werbos
• The cosine-0.8854 meta-pairing between the RHW/DOCSUB bridge-check note and the confirmed Fel'dbaum-bridge note is an object-level embedding false friend, with a real but uncited mechanism-equivalence rooted two centuries deeper, in Lagrange and Hamilton
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-10-06 · bipartite-bridge, embedding-false-friend, jingle-fallacy, werbos, backpropagation
• The Olsder-backlink and Werbos-obscurity observation notes are not a false friend: both are instances of one recurring, already-fixed-elsewhere vault maintenance mechanism (one-directional hub backlinks), and the two notes have never been cross-linked to each other
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-10-05 · moc-maintenance, backlink-gap, structural-gap, werbos, backpropagation
• The RHW/DOCSUB thematic-not-causal verdict and the Greenhalgh/Kwakernaak/Kaelbling/Åström confirmed-Fel'dbaum-bridge verdict are an object-level false friend, but both subjects share a genuine, uncited, two-centuries-deeper common mathematical ancestor in Lagrange and Hamilton
  capture promoted 2026-10-04 · bipartite-bridge, embedding-false-friend, jingle-fallacy, werbos, backpropagation
• Fel'dbaum didn't just get co-cited with Pontryagin — his engineering work personally catalyzed the maximum principle
  capture promoted Tier 2 2026-10-04 · feldbaum, pontryagin, optimal-control, cold-war, cybernetics
• ChainQueen's differentiable Material Point Method simulator back-propagates through MPM using the reverse-mode technique Linnainmaa's 1976 algorithm first described
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-10-04 · linnainmaa, automatic-differentiation, backpropagation, material-point-method, chainqueen
• The cosine pairing between the ML/AD-En Gedi and Brooks/Werbos false-friend notes is itself an embedding false friend, not a confirmed meta-bridge
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-10-03 · embedding-false-friend, cosine-similarity, jingle-fallacy, bridge-taxonomy, backpropagation
• claim-werbos-attributes-early-obscurity-to-publishing-strategy-not-suppression is missing from moc-backpropagation-origins, despite three cited sibling notes already being listed there
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-10-03 · moc-maintenance, werbos, backpropagation, structural-gap, argument-from-silence
• Paul Werbos is a partial, asymmetric person-bridge between the ML/AD mutual-unawareness claim and his own obscurity testimony — one level below a meta-pairing that is itself a false friend
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-10-03 · paul-werbos, person-bridge, backpropagation, automatic-differentiation, multiple-independent-discovery
• Does Kelley-Bryson's discrete costate recursion reduce to Pontryagin's continuous adjoint equations in the small-step limit?
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-10-01 · kelley-bryson, pontryagin, optimal-control, adjoint-method, costate
• Differentiating a discretized neural-ODE forward pass and discretizing the continuous adjoint ODE give provably different, sometimes divergent, gradients
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-10-01 · neural-odes, adjoint-method, discretize-then-optimize, optimize-then-discretize, numerical-analysis
• The discrete Kelley-Bryson costate recursion and Pontryagin's continuous adjoint are the same object only inside a hypothesis-bound regime; outside it they are a family resemblance, not an identity
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-10-01 · pontryagin, kelley-bryson, costate, adjoint-method, optimal-control
• The bridge between Werbos's TSP-manual 'first publication' claim and his 1988 DOE gas-market paper is not a false friend — it is the same physical document
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-09-29 · bipartite-bridge, paul-werbos, tsp-manual, natural-gas-market-model, department-of-energy
• Bipartite hop: the cosine-0.83 pairing between Werbos's publishing-strategy testimony and Isaacs's no-colleagues silence is an object-level false friend; the real connection is that both are unregistered members of the vault's own argument-from-silence family, sitting at its two most extreme poles
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-09-29 · bipartite-bridge, argument-from-silence, embedding-false-friend, rufus-isaacs, paul-werbos
• Werbos's 1988 paper credits Karl Deutsch's political-forecasting project — not his own dissertation or the TSP manual — as backpropagation's 'first actual application'
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-09-29 · paul-werbos, karl-deutsch, backpropagation, history-of-ml, priority-vs-paternity
• Werbos's 1988 print account is a second, earlier-dated attestation of the TSP manual's role — narrowing but not closing the single-witness gap on the manual's content
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-09-29 · paul-werbos, tsp-manual, backpropagation, history-of-ml, sourcing
• Werbos's 1988 print account names his 1974 dissertation, not the TSP manual, as the first place the backpropagation-generalization results were documented
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-09-29 · paul-werbos, tsp-manual, backpropagation, history-of-ml, priority-vs-paternity
• Werbos's 1988 DOE gas-market paper and the TSP-manual 'first publication' claim rest on the same physical document, not a false friend
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-09-29 · bipartite-bridge, paul-werbos, tsp-manual, natural-gas-market-model, department-of-energy
• MOC: Testimony is not a record — Werbos's priority narrative, examined as documents
  topic map 2026-09-29 · moc, werbos, backpropagation, diplomatics, single-witness
• Brooks's 1986 rebuttal-target citation and Werbos's 1981 EIA documentation connect through a shared named person, Stuart Dreyfus — not a false friend, but not a direct Brooks–Werbos link either
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-09-28 · bipartite-bridge, rodney-brooks, hubert-dreyfus, stuart-dreyfus, paul-werbos
• Stuart Dreyfus's 1990 paper names Werbos as the researcher usually credited with backpropagation, calls his derivation independent, and argues proper priority belongs to Kelley and Bryson
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-09-28 · stuart-dreyfus, paul-werbos, kelley-bryson, backpropagation, optimal-control
• Stuart Dreyfus person-bridges Brooks's 1986 rebuttal-target citation and the Kelley-Bryson-Werbos backpropagation-priority dispute Werbos's EIA gas-market work later ran into — a mediated bridge, not a false friend, not a direct link
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-09-28 · bipartite-bridge, person-bridge, rodney-brooks, hubert-dreyfus, stuart-dreyfus
• Bipartite hop: does the cosine-0.84 pairing between claim-garfield-1980-survey-omits-chandler (epistemology) and claim-werbos-docsub-report-and-rhws-missing-1974-thesis-are-different-documents (ml-ai) reveal a real bridge, or is it a false friend?
  capture promoted 2026-09-27 · multiple-discovery, priority-dispute, merton, chandler, garfield
• Capture: Does a genuine mechanism connect Linnainmaa's 1976 citation histogram and OSTI's structured-metadata confirmation of SAND-91-7095's date, or is the cosine-0.84 pairing a false friend?
  capture promoted 2026-09-27 · bridge-investigation, cosine-similarity, embedding-false-friend, linnainmaa, automatic-differentiation
• Werbos (1988) pp. 350-355 body text: no mention of Isaacs, Bellman, Pontryagin, Kelley, or Bryson
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-09-26 · werbos, isaacs, bellman, pontryagin, kelley
• Werbos's 1988 body text on pp. 350-355 (recurrent derivation, gas-model application, conclusion) names none of Isaacs, Bellman, Pontryagin, Kelley, or Bryson
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-09-26 · werbos, isaacs, bellman, pontryagin, kelley
• The JMLR survey anchoring the vault's ML/AD mutual-unawareness claim is co-authored by Barak Pearlmutter, a researcher whose own career spans the divide the survey describes
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-09-26 · automatic-differentiation, backpropagation, barak-pearlmutter, community-structure, history-of-ml
• The NIPS-founders / Kwakernaak-Twente-founding cosine-0.85 pairing is an embedding false friend — two 'who founded X' retrospectives that share documentary genre, not a link, while the real field-level lineage runs one level up and touches neither founding event
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-09-26 · embedding-false-friend, cosine-similarity, nips, neurips, huibert-kwakernaak
• Does Yaser Abu-Mostafa's own learning-theory work cite any optimal-control / LQG source directly?
  question open 2026-09-26 · nips, neurips, yaser-abu-mostafa, optimal-control, lqg
• Isaacs (1951) and Werbos (1988) share a mechanism — a scalar terminal quantity's gradient carried backward along a path — but no documented transmission line: the resemblance is real at the level of adjoint/costate structure and absent at the level of citation
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-09-25 · bipartite-bridge, rufus-isaacs, paul-werbos, backpropagation, differential-games
• Werbos's 1988 paper equates his 'dynamic feedback' backward recursion of ordered derivatives with control theory's time-dependent Lagrange multipliers, and calls it 'very similar to earlier methods from control theory'
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-09-25 · werbos, backpropagation, dynamic-feedback, ordered-derivatives, adjoint-method
• Werbos's 1988 reference list contains no Isaacs, Bellman, Pontryagin, Kelley, or Bryson; his documented control-theory lines run through Athans & Kalb (1966) and Oak Ridge adjoint sensitivity work
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-09-25 · werbos, isaacs, backpropagation, citation-analysis, negative-evidence
• Bipartite hop: NIPS's founders (Posner/Abu-Mostafa) and Kwakernaak's 1970 founding of Twente Systems and Control share no direct link — the real mechanism connecting their FIELDS is the vault's own disciplinary-wall thread, one level removed from either founding event
  capture promoted 2026-09-21 · nips, neurips, huibert-kwakernaak, university-of-twente, control-theory
• Bipartite hop: what connects observation-ml-ad-en-gedi-cosine-pairing-is-embedding-false-friend and observation-brooks-werbos-cosine-085-pairing-is-embedding-false-friend
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-09-21 · embedding-false-friend, cosine-similarity, jingle-fallacy, backpropagation, werbos
• Hinton's 2022 Forward-Forward paper cites 'Rumelhart et al., 1986' as bare shorthand for backpropagation — a live instance of the anchoring effect the 1986-demonstration claim names
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-09-19 · hinton, backpropagation, forward-forward, rumelhart, history-of-ml
• The 0.87 cosine pairing between Hinton's 2007→2022 backprop-in-the-brain arc and the RHW 1986 'demonstration not invention' claim is thematic resemblance, not a causal bridge
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-09-19 · hinton, backpropagation, biological-plausibility, forward-forward, history-of-ml
• The KAN paper's own account: neural implementations of the Kolmogorov-Arnold theorem had been tried repeatedly before 2024 but stalled at a fixed shallow form, lacking modern techniques like backpropagation
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-09-16 · kolmogorov, arnold, neural-networks, ai, backpropagation
• What genuinely connects Hinton's 2007→2022 reversal on backprop-in-the-brain and the 1986 Nature paper's 'demonstration, not invention' contribution?
  capture promoted 2026-09-13 · hinton, backpropagation, biological-plausibility, forward-forward, history-of-ml
• Do Steinbuch & Widrow 1965 and Widrow's 1966 'Bootstrap Learning' actually document the abandoned multilayer-training attempt — and what does Widrow's oral history say about the 1985 return?
  capture promoted 2026-09-05 · widrow, steinbuch, madaline, bootstrap-learning, multilayer-perceptron
• Widrow's 1966 'Bootstrap Learning' paper documents a genuine, preliminary, non-gradient attempt at training multilayer networks of adaptive threshold elements
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-09-05 · widrow, madaline, bootstrap-learning, multilayer-perceptron, backpropagation
• Does Merton's 'obliteration by incorporation' (OBI) concept, read directly from his 1988 paper, map onto the backpropagation citation gap?
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-09-02 · sociology-of-science, robert-merton, obliteration-by-incorporation, matthew-effect, backpropagation
• The backpropagation citation gap is Merton's Matthew Effect, not his obliteration by incorporation
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-09-02 · sociology-of-science, robert-merton, obliteration-by-incorporation, matthew-effect, backpropagation
• Merton's OBI caveat that erasure is "evident to knowing peers" fails for the backpropagation gap
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-09-02 · sociology-of-science, robert-merton, obliteration-by-incorporation, backpropagation, historiography
• A receipt for the mechanism, not a law — brain and machine invert on whether learning or using is the cheaper operation, yet both spend most of their energy signalling/inferring; 'training is the expensive phase' is a property of backpropagation, not a law of learning systems
  topic map 2026-08-25 · neuroenergetics, brain-energy-budget, training-inference-asymmetry, inference-economics, synaptic-plasticity
• Werbos's DOCSUB/thesis document-identity claim is a third leg of the single June 1993 oral-history cluster — and the only leg with independent corroboration
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-08-22 · werbos, docsub, darpa, backpropagation, oral-history
• Bipartite hop: does the cosine-0.86 pairing between the Gates-Jevons 'embedding false friend' note and the RHW/DOCSUB 'thematic not causal' note reveal a real bridge, or is it a second-order false friend?
  capture promoted 2026-08-20 · embedding-false-friend, cosine-similarity, jingle-fallacy, retrieval, epistemics
• The cosine-0.86 pairing between the vault's RHW/DOCSUB and Gates-Jevons 'embedding false friend' observation notes is a hedged case — real at the level of authorial method, false at the level of grounding
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-08-20 · embedding-false-friend, cosine-similarity, jingle-fallacy, retrieval, epistemics
• What genuinely connects Werbos's two missing-document claims and the DOCSUB/RHW-thesis document-identity claim? The same 1993 sitting, with one leg independently corroborated
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-08-19 · werbos, docsub, darpa, backpropagation, oral-history
• What genuinely connects the RHW 1986 four-reference list and Werbos's DOCSUB block? Chronology and document identity say: nothing causal
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-08-17 · werbos, rumelhart, backpropagation, citation-history, docsub
• Werbos's DOCSUB episode entered the public record 7–12 years after RHW's 1986 Nature paper, foreclosing a causal reading
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-08-17 · werbos, rumelhart, backpropagation, citation-history, docsub
• Werbos's own explanation for his early non-recognition is publishing strategy, not DARPA suppression — and Kanal's independent testimony agrees
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-08-17 · werbos, kanal, obscurity, citation-history, backpropagation
• The DARPA report blocked from DOCSUB and the 1974 Harvard thesis RHW failed to cite are two different Werbos documents
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-08-17 · werbos, docsub, darpa, backpropagation, citation-history
• The 0.87 cosine pairing between the RHW 1986 reference list and Werbos's DOCSUB block is thematic resemblance, not a causal bridge
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-08-17 · embeddings, cosine-similarity, retrieval, epistemics, werbos
• Werbos's two "missing document" claims — the lost 1968 Cybernetica paper and the blocked 1978 DARPA report — trace to a single June 1993 oral-history sitting, not two independent corroborations
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-08-07 · werbos, backpropagation, oral-history, single-witness, sourcing
• What is the actual model architecture of HNC's Falcon Fraud Manager — is it specifically a supervised backpropagation feedforward network?
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-08-02 · hnc, falcon, fico, fraud-detection, neural-networks
• HNC's founding 1992 Falcon patent specifies backpropagation gradient descent as a supervised training method
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-08-02 · hnc, falcon, fico, fraud-detection, neural-networks
• Werbos's two 'missing backpropagation document' claims — the lost 1968 paper and the blocked 1978 DARPA report — trace to the same single 1993 interview
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-08-01 · werbos, backpropagation, oral-history, single-witness, sourcing
• Deutsch rescued Werbos's rejected PhD by handing him his own political-forecasting problem — and solving it under a compute budget is Werbos's own reason backpropagation got generalized to recurrent form
  claim seedling Tier 2 2026-08-01 · karl-deutsch, werbos, backpropagation, recurrent, beyond-regression
• Werbos didn't just test backpropagation on a DOE gas market model — he was the federal analyst who wrote its official documentation, for the study that evaluated U.S. natural gas deregulation
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-31 · werbos, department-of-energy, natural-gas-market-model, energy-policy, natural-gas-deregulation
• Werbos's 1988 backpropagation-generalization paper lists his affiliation as the U.S. Department of Energy, and its real-world test case was a DOE-developed natural gas market model
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-31 · werbos, department-of-energy, natural-gas-market-model, energy-policy, history-of-ml
• Dup-risk stub: the LeCun-1989/Werbos-1968 note pair (cosine 0.87) is cluster density, not a bridge
  capture promoted 2026-07-30 · backpropagation, werbos, lecun, dup-risk, seed-resolution
• Karl Deutsch, Werbos's Harvard advisor, wrote political science's founding cybernetics text — and personally redirected the rejected Freud-into-math project into the thesis that generalized backpropagation
  capture promoted Tier 2 2026-07-30 · werbos, karl-deutsch, cybernetics, political-science, backpropagation
• Werbos's own 1988 paper states RHW's 1986 backpropagation is a mathematical special case of his general 1974 'dynamic feedback' framework
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-29 · werbos, backpropagation, rhw-1986, priority-vs-paternity, history-of-ml
• Werbos's own 1988 paper states RHW's 1986 backpropagation is a special case of his 1974 "dynamic feedback" framework
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-29 · werbos, backpropagation, rhw-1986, priority-vs-paternity, history-of-ml
• The only text of Dreyfus 1973 reachable this session is a triangulated abstract, and it contains no explicit controllers-as-weights language
  claim seedling Tier 2 for the access-status finding (Semantic Scholar / Unpaywall); [unverified-mechanism — needs primary] for anything about the paper's actual content, since the abstract above is triangulated via aggregator metadata and search-snippet matching, never directly fetched from the IEEE Xplore record itself 2026-07-20 · dreyfus, schmidhuber, backpropagation, optimal-control, history-of-ml
• Schmidhuber's 'controllers-as-weights' framing for Dreyfus 1973 is confirmed only in Schmidhuber's own words, on two of his own venues
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-07-20 · dreyfus, schmidhuber, backpropagation, optimal-control, history-of-ml
• The vault's cosine-0.75 pairing between the ML/AD mutual-unawareness claim and the En-Gedi virtual-unwrapping claim is an embedding false friend — shared temporal-arc vocabulary, not shared phenomenon
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-07-20 · embeddings, cosine-similarity, embedding-false-friend, en-gedi, virtual-unwrapping
• Seales/Mocella is a third pole on the vault's multiple-discovery axis: acknowledged, citation-based convergence — never independent, never forgotten
  observation seedling 2026-07-20 · multiple-discovery, historiography, priority, virtual-unwrapping, en-gedi
• Does Dreyfus's 1973 'time-lag optimal control' paper actually contain the controllers-as-weights backprop step Schmidhuber attributes to it?
  capture promoted Tier mixed — see per-claim fields 2026-07-19 · dreyfus, schmidhuber, backpropagation, optimal-control, history-of-ml
• The En-Gedi/backprop resemblance is superficial — virtual unwrapping's history is acknowledged convergence, not mutual unawareness, and the vault already has the axis to place it on
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-19 · multiple-discovery, historiography, virtual-unwrapping, automatic-differentiation, backpropagation
• The ML/AD-unaware <-> En-Gedi cosine-0.75 pairing is another embedding false friend
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-18 · embeddings, cosine-similarity, embedding-false-friend, en-gedi, virtual-unwrapping
• Restricting plasticity to large, coordinated synaptic updates keeps biological learning cheap — unrestricted backprop would need ~100,000x more synaptic updates in macaque V1
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-07-12 · neuroenergetics, synaptic-plasticity, gradient-sparsification, backpropagation, learning-mechanism
• 'Credit assignment' names both the sociology of scientific credit and backpropagation's technical problem — and Schmidhuber sits on the hinge
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-07-12 · credit-assignment, sociology-of-science, schmidhuber, backpropagation, history-of-ml
• Chen et al. (2018), 'Neural Ordinary Differential Equations,' cite Pontryagin by name for the adjoint sensitivity method and equate it with reverse-mode automatic differentiation / backpropagation
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-07-12 · pontryagin, adjoint-method, neural-ode, backpropagation, reverse-mode-ad
• Schmidhuber's 'Annotated History of Modern AI and Deep Learning' dates the field's origin to the 1676 chain rule and circa-1800 neural nets — reading the present category back onto the deep past
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-07-12 · whig-history, historiography-of-ai, presentism, schmidhuber, credit-assignment
• Parker's erased backprop report and the LabVIEW/Max convergence are opposite poles of the multiple-discovery axis — real independence forgotten vs. apparent independence over-remembered
  observation seedling Tier 3 2026-07-12 · multiple-discovery, independent-convergence, historiography, dataflow, visual-programming
• Persistent homology is a gradient-free structural diagnostic that bridges Widrow's derivative-blocked Madaline stall and the Byzantine trade network's topological collapse
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-07-12 · persistent-homology, topological-data-analysis, generalization, backpropagation, widrow
• David Rumelhart is the unnamed hinge connecting the vault's schema-change cluster and its backpropagation-origins cluster — one trajectory from the 1978 tuning/restructuring taxonomy to the 1986 backprop revival
  observation seedling Tier 4 2026-07-12 · rumelhart, connectionism, schema-theory, backpropagation, ai-history
• Does Merton's 'obliteration by incorporation' (OBI) concept, read directly from his 1988 paper, map onto the backpropagation citation gap?
  question answered 2026-07-12 · sociology-of-science, merton, obliteration-by-incorporation, backpropagation, credit-assignment
• Did Rumelhart himself frame schema 'tuning' (1978) as a deliberate through-line to gradient-descent weight-tuning (1986), or is the 'tuning' echo retrospective?
  question answered 2026-07-12 · rumelhart, schema-theory, backpropagation, connectionism, tuning
• Dup-risk: the Linnainmaa-thesis / Werbos-IEEE-awards bridge is real but already saturated in the vault
  note promoted 2026-07-11 · dup-risk, backpropagation, linnainmaa, werbos, myth-ledger
• In the brain, learning is metabolically cheap and signaling is expensive — the per-event reverse of AI's training-heavy compute asymmetry
  capture promoted 2026-07-11 · neuroenergetics, synaptic-plasticity, inference-economics, training-inference-asymmetry, cross-domain-bridge
• Priority adjudication is documentary source criticism — and Merton is the hinge to Mabillon
  capture promoted Tier 3 2026-07-11 · history-of-science, priority, multiple-discovery, diplomatics, source-criticism
• Parker's erased report and the LabVIEW/Max convergence are opposite poles of the multiple-discovery axis — real independence forgotten vs. false independence remembered
  capture promoted Tier 3 2026-07-11 · multiple-discovery, independent-convergence, dataflow, visual-programming, labview
• The 1973 AI establishment named the wall: McCarthy called control theory 'little relevance to AI' — the field where backprop's ancestor already lived
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-11 · lighthill-report, mccarthy, control-theory, optimal-control, combinatorial-explosion
• The Werbos–Oaksford/Chater bridge is real but relocated — optimization-as-theory-of-mind, and the objective function fixes the verdict
  capture promoted Tier 4 2026-07-11 · optimization, theory-of-mind, rational-analysis, werbos, oaksford-chater
• Topology sees what the gradient could not — persistent homology bridges Widrow's stall and the Byzantine trade collapse
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-11 · persistent-homology, topological-data-analysis, generalization, backpropagation, widrow
• The vault's exemplar blind mathematician, Pontryagin, is an unacknowledged root of backpropagation's optimal-control ancestry
  capture promoted 2026-07-11 · pontryagin, optimal-control, maximum-principle, adjoint-method, costate
• David Rumelhart is the hinge under both seed notes — he coined the tuning/restructuring taxonomy AND co-led the backprop revival
  capture promoted Tier 2 2026-07-11 · rumelhart, connectionism, schema-theory, backpropagation, prediction-error
• Substrate-laundering — output resemblance underdetermines mechanism, and the substrate's rigor is the vector of the error
  capture promoted Tier 2 2026-07-11 · underdetermination, marr-levels, mechanism, epistemics, cross-domain-bridge
• Whig history names what the vault's AI-history myth-ledger polices — and Weinberg's science exemption complicates it
  capture promoted Tier 2 2026-07-11 · whig-history, historiography-of-ai, presentism, credit-assignment, backpropagation
• Bjork's and Dreyfus's disproven misattributions are the same move — an argument from silence — that McGrew's grading separates: Bjork's is airtight, Dreyfus's is the weaker mediated form
  observation seedling Tier 1 2026-07-11 · argument-from-silence, historiography, negative-evidence, bayesian, methodology
• Does Dreyfus's 1973 'time-lag optimal control' paper actually contain the controllers-as-weights backprop step Schmidhuber attributes to it?
  question open 2026-07-11 · dreyfus, schmidhuber, backpropagation, argument-from-silence, priority-dispute
• Did LeCun's 1988 paper use hand-designed rather than learned convolutional kernels, and is that the basis for calling 1989 the first end-to-end trained convnet?
  capture promoted Tier 1 (bibliographic facts) / 4 (mechanism claim — see flags below) 2026-07-09 · lecun, denker, bell-labs, backpropagation, convolutional-neural-networks
• Dreyfus's own 1988 account resolves the 'double role': his critique targeted symbolic AI specifically, and he framed connectionism as vindicating his phenomenology, not as its target
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-09 · dreyfus, connectionism, phenomenology, backpropagation, perceptrons
• Exact publication year and page range of the NETtalk paper (Sejnowski & Rosenberg)
  capture promoted Tier 1-2 (see per-claim notes; primary PDF text could not be directly rendered in this environment — see caveat) 2026-07-09 · nettalk, sejnowski, rosenberg, backpropagation, connectionism
• Capture: Which appeared first — LeCun et al.'s NIPS 1989 conference paper or their Neural Computation 1989 journal paper on backprop for handwritten digit recognition?
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-09 · lecun, bell-labs, backpropagation, nips, neural-computation
• LeCun et al.'s two 1989 ZIP-code papers appeared in a bimodal order: the NIPS conference paper was presented first (Nov 1989), the Neural Computation article was printed first (Dec 1989), and the NIPS proceedings volume only appeared in 1990
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-09 · lecun, bell-labs, backpropagation, nips, neural-computation
• Madaline Rule I (1962) could adapt only the first layer of Widrow's networks — the second layer stayed fixed, making it the ceiling of pre-backpropagation multilayer training
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-09 · widrow, madaline, adaline, multilayer-perceptron, backpropagation
• The NETtalk paper is Sejnowski & Rosenberg's 1987 Complex Systems 1(1):145–168 article — a distinct document from their 1986 Johns Hopkins technical report of the same name
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-09 · nettalk, sejnowski, rosenberg, backpropagation, connectionism
• Widrow's group spent the 1960s unable to train a genuinely multilayer network and left neural-net research until backpropagation reached Widrow in the mid-1980s
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-09 · widrow, madaline, adaline, multilayer-perceptron, backpropagation
• Myth ledger: "LeCun's 1988 paper used hand-designed convolutional kernels" — the 1988 hand-designed-kernel ZIP-code paper was Denker et al., not LeCun
  note budding Tier 1 2026-07-09 · lecun, denker, bell-labs, convolutional-neural-networks, backpropagation
• Do Steinbuch & Widrow 1965 and Widrow's 1966 'Bootstrap Learning' actually document the abandoned multilayer-training attempt — and what does Widrow's oral history say about the 1985 return?
  question open 2026-07-09 · widrow, madaline, multilayer-perceptron, backpropagation, history-of-ml
• Did Widrow attempt and abandon multilayer network training around 1965–1966, and what primary sources document this effort?
  capture promoted 2026-07-08 · widrow, madaline, adaline, multilayer-perceptron, backpropagation
• Capture: Dedupe-check on '[ANSWERED 2026-07-07, cycle 17; venue was wrong — BIT 16, not Annales] Yes on both counts' topic — confirms claim-linnainmaa-1976-algorithm-t-reverse-sweep is real, accurate, and re-corroborated; no new research warranted
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-08 · automatic-differentiation, linnainmaa, reverse-mode-ad, backpropagation, history-of-computation
• Hinton's mature position (Lillicrap et al. 2020) is that the brain can implement backprop's core principles — not strict backpropagation — via NGRAD, feedback-induced activity differences that locally approximate error signals
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-08 · hinton, lillicrap, backpropagation, ngrad, biological-plausibility
• Hinton's position on backpropagation-in-the-brain reversed over fifteen years — the 2007 talk tried to rescue it with a temporal-derivative mechanism; the 2022 Forward-Forward paper abandoned it
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-08 · hinton, backpropagation, biological-plausibility, forward-forward, contrastive-divergence
• Werbos traces backpropagation's earliest germ to a real 1968 Cybernetica paper — but its Freud-to-dynamic-programming content survives only as his own later paraphrase, not the paper's own words
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-07-08 · werbos, backpropagation, freud, cybernetica, priority
• Did Bryson & Ho's Applied Optimal Control (1969) serve as a curriculum transmission vector for adjoint/gradient methods, and what does the argmin blog cite it as evidence of?
  capture promoted 2026-07-07 · backpropagation, optimal-control, history-of-AI, adjoint-method, Bryson-Ho
• What exactly did Dreyfus (1973) publish on error-gradient-proportional controller adaptation, and does it constitute a verifiable intermediate step in the backpropagation lineage?
  capture promoted 2026-07-07 · backpropagation, optimal-control, history-of-AI, Kelley-Bryson, Dreyfus
• What duality argument does the Argmin "Mates of Costate" post make connecting adjoint variables/co-state equations to Bryson (1961) and Kalman (1960), and does it support a backprop lineage through optimal control?
  capture promoted 2026-07-07 · backpropagation, optimal-control, history-of-AI, Kelley-Bryson, Kalman-filter
• Capture: Did Werbos's 1974 Harvard PhD thesis explicitly frame backpropagation as a solution to the spatial credit assignment problem, and in what terms?
  capture promoted Tier 2 2026-07-07 · werbos, backpropagation, credit-assignment, harvard, history-of-ai
• Capture: Speelpenning's 1980 thesis bibliography (leaf 74) does not cite Linnainmaa — full-text PDF retrieved from OSTI.gov
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-07 · speelpenning, linnainmaa, automatic-differentiation, reverse-mode, backpropagation
• Year-by-year citation counts for Linnainmaa 1976 (DOI 10.1007/BF01931367) — Semantic Scholar histogram, cross-checked against Google Scholar
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-07 · linnainmaa, backpropagation, automatic-differentiation, citation-history, citation-analysis
• Capture: Does section 5.5.1 of Werbos's 1974 Harvard thesis 'Beyond Regression' explicitly name Linnainmaa as a prior source, or is it an independent derivation?
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-07 · werbos, linnainmaa, backpropagation, automatic-differentiation, harvard
• Backpropagation is the special case of reverse-mode automatic differentiation applied to a network's evaluation function composed with a scalar loss
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-07 · backpropagation, reverse-mode-ad, automatic-differentiation, chain-rule, mechanism
• Applied Optimal Control (1969) was compiled from six years of Harvard, MIT, and AIAA courses — the adjoint method's curriculum vector, by Bryson's own account
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-07 · bryson-ho, optimal-control, adjoint-method, curriculum, history-of-ml
• The reverse-mode "cheap gradient" bound has two figures — "one to four times" (the book's prose) and "5×" (the Baur-Strassen formalization) — and they don't contradict
  claim seedling Tier 2 2026-07-07 · automatic-differentiation, reverse-mode, cheap-gradient-principle, baur-strassen, computational-complexity
• Schmidhuber's "Dreyfus 1973" backprop-lineage link is uncorroborated by Dreyfus himself — both of Dreyfus's own retrospectives credit his 1962 paper and never cite 1973
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-07-07 · dreyfus, schmidhuber, backpropagation, optimal-control, history-of-ml
• Kelley (1960) and Bryson (1961) computed gradients through multi-stage systems by backward chain-rule iteration — a precursor lacking backpropagation's sparsity efficiencies
  claim budding Tier 2 2026-07-07 · kelley, bryson, optimal-control, backpropagation, history-of-ml
• LeCun et al. (1989) at Bell Labs made the first practical recognition application of backpropagation — handwritten ZIP codes, end-to-end
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-07 · lecun, bell-labs, backpropagation, cnn, zip-codes
• Linnainmaa 1976's citation record, finally pulled — 51 dated citations across 1978–2009, then 245 in the sixteen years since 2010
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-07 · linnainmaa, citation-history, bibliometrics, backpropagation, myth-ledger
• The machine-learning and automatic-differentiation communities were mutually unaware until "very recently" — the structural cause of the backprop attribution gap
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-07 · automatic-differentiation, backpropagation, citation-history, history-of-ml, linnainmaa
• Recht's "Mates of Costate" argues mathematical equivalence (Lagrangian duality), not historical transmission — and never mentions Kelley
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-07 · recht, optimal-control, lagrangian-duality, adjoint-method, backpropagation
• The 1986 Nature paper's contribution was demonstrating that backpropagation learns useful internal representations — not inventing the algorithm
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-07 · rumelhart, hinton, williams, backpropagation, internal-representations
• Werbos's 1974 thesis never mentions Linnainmaa — and Schmidhuber's "Section 5.5.1" locator doesn't structurally exist in the 1974 text
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-07 · werbos, linnainmaa, backpropagation, independent-discovery, history-of-ml
• The 1974 Werbos thesis contains no credit-assignment language at all — "backprop solves spatial credit assignment (Werbos 1974)" is a retrospective label
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-07 · werbos, credit-assignment, backpropagation, history-of-ml, retrospective-framing
• Werbos, on the record — DARPA kept his backpropagation report out of DOCSUB, and the 1978 journal version shipped without the how-to appendix
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-07 · werbos, darpa, docsub, backpropagation, history-of-ml
• Werbos's 2011 IJCNN paper states the Freud mapping explicitly — cathexis is the derivative, and the "A causes B" quote is Werbos quoting Freud
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-07 · werbos, freud, cathexis, backpropagation, derivatives
• In his own account, Werbos built backpropagation to translate Freud's "psychic energy" into derivative equations — not to train a supervised learner
  claim budding Tier 2 2026-07-07 · werbos, freud, backpropagation, psychic-energy, history-of-ml
• IEEE gave Werbos the Neural Networks Pioneer Award in 1995 (jointly) and the Frank Rosenblatt Award in 2022 — the 2022 citation credits him with "development of backpropagation"
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-07 · werbos, ieee, awards, backpropagation, history-of-ml
• Werbos says generalized backpropagation was first published as a command in an MIT software manual — the manual is bibliographically real, but no copy can be located
  claim seedling Tier 2 2026-07-07 · werbos, backpropagation, tsp, mit, history-of-ml
• Capture: Did IEEE award Paul Werbos the Neural Network Pioneer Award in 1995 and the Frank Rosenblatt Award in 2022?
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-06 · werbos, ieee, awards, backpropagation, history-of-ml
• Capture: Did Linnainmaa originate reverse-mode automatic differentiation, per Griewank's 2012 Documenta Mathematica history paper?
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-06 · automatic-differentiation, linnainmaa, griewank, backpropagation, reverse-mode
• Capture: How does forward-mode AD via dual numbers compute Jacobian-vector products, and what is its structural relationship to reverse-mode AD?
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-06 · automatic-differentiation, forward-mode-ad, dual-numbers, jacobian-vector-product, reverse-mode
• Capture: Is "training-vs-inference compute asymmetry" the missing bridge note between the vault's two biggest clusters?
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-06 · gap-detection, missing-bridge, inference, backpropagation, compute-economics
• What did Lillicrap et al. (2016, Nature Communications) actually demonstrate with feedback alignment, and on what grounds do critics dispute that it constitutes backpropagation?
  capture promoted 2026-07-06 · feedback-alignment, backpropagation, biological-plausibility, weight-transport-problem, timothy-lillicrap
• What exact numeric bound does Griewank & Walther (2008) state for reverse-mode cost relative to the original function's cost in the "cheap gradient principle"?
  capture promoted Tier 2 2026-07-06 · automatic-differentiation, reverse-mode, cheap-gradient-principle, griewank-walther, baur-strassen
• Capture: Does Werbos's 1968 Cybernetica paper exist, and what does it actually say about the Freud-to-mathematics idea?
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-06 · werbos, backpropagation, history-of-ml, freud, cybernetica
• Capture: What is the exact primary source of Werbos's Freudian "A causes B" backpropagation mechanism — is it in *The Roots of Backpropagation* (1994) or elsewhere?
  capture promoted Tier 4 2026-07-06 · werbos, backpropagation, history-of-ml, freud, roots-of-backpropagation
• Capture: Can the MIT Time Series Processor (TSP) software manual (Brode, Werbos, Dunn) be located, and does it contain the first published description of Werbos's generalized backpropagation method?
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-06 · werbos, backpropagation, history-of-ml, tsp, mit
• Capture: Did Werbos's 1978 IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics paper omit technical appendices because DARPA blocked entry of the fuller report into the DOD public document system?
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-06 · werbos, backpropagation, history-of-ml, darpa, dod
• Capture: Did Crick (1989) 'The recent excitement about neural networks' (Nature 337:129–132) first formally state the weight transport problem, predating Hinton's 2022 formulation?
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-06 · crick, weight-transport-problem, backpropagation, biological-plausibility, hinton
• Capture: What is Hinton's exact qualified position on the brain approximating backprop, as stated in Lillicrap et al. (2020) 'Backpropagation and the brain,' NRN 21(6)?
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-06 · hinton, lillicrap, backpropagation, ngrad, biological-plausibility
• What Hinton argued in his 2007 talk 'How to do backpropagation in a brain' — and how it anticipates his later published critique
  capture promoted 2026-07-06 · geoffrey-hinton, backpropagation, biological-plausibility, forward-forward, contrastive-divergence
• What is "update locking" in parallel computing literature, and how precisely does it map to the backward-pass sequentiality constraint in backpropagation?
  capture promoted 2026-07-06 · update-locking, forward-locking, backward-locking, parallel-computing, backpropagation
• Does Hinton's Forward-Forward paper explicitly cite Boltzmann machines as a prototype, and how do contrastive Hebbian learning and equilibrium propagation relate as biologically plausible alternatives to backpropagation?
  capture promoted 2026-07-06 · geoffrey-hinton, forward-forward, boltzmann-machine, contrastive-hebbian-learning, equilibrium-propagation
• Did Kelley (1960) derive the optimal-control gradient via adjoint equations and Green's theorem?
  capture promoted 2026-07-06 · backpropagation, optimal-control, history-of-AI, adjoint-method, Greens-theorem
• What formal derivation does Mizutani & Dreyfus (2000) provide linking MLP backpropagation to the Kelley-Bryson optimal-control gradient formula?
  capture promoted 2026-07-06 · backpropagation, optimal-control, Kelley-Bryson, dynamic-programming, Mizutani-Dreyfus
• Mizutani, Dreyfus & Nishio (2000) formally derive MLP backpropagation as a special case of the Kelley-Bryson optimal-control gradient formula
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-06 · dreyfus, kelley-bryson, optimal-control, backpropagation, formal-derivation
• Crick's 1989 objection to backprop was antidromic signalling, NOT weight transport — a circulating attribution the primary text refutes
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-06 · crick, weight-transport, biological-plausibility, backpropagation, citation-correction
• Feedback alignment shows fixed random feedback weights can train networks to near-backprop accuracy — but whether it "is" backpropagation is disputed
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-06 · feedback-alignment, biological-plausibility, backpropagation, weight-transport, lillicrap
• Hinton's "biologically implausible" is four specific objections — weight transport, a separate backward pass, discrete synchronized cycles, and required differentiability
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-06 · hinton, biological-plausibility, backpropagation, neuroscience, weight-transport
• David Parker's 1985 backprop rediscovery was an internal MIT technical report (TR-47), credited by RHW 1986 only as "personal communication" with no reference entry
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-06 · parker, backpropagation, technical-report, citation-history, rumelhart
• The 1986 backpropagation Nature paper cites only four references — none of the earlier independent derivations
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-06 · rumelhart, hinton, williams, backpropagation, citation-history
• Update locking names backprop's sequential constraint: a layer cannot update until the full forward and backward passes complete
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-06 · update-locking, backpropagation, synthetic-gradients, parallelism, deepmind
• The vanishing gradient problem is a chain-rule pathology — early layers stop learning as gradient magnitudes diverge across depth
  claim budding Tier 4 2026-07-06 · vanishing-gradient, backpropagation, chain-rule, deep-learning, training-pathology
• Myth ledger: 'Paul Werbos invented backpropagation'
  note budding 2026-07-06 · myth, werbos, backpropagation, priority, history-of-ml
• MOC: Backpropagation's origins — priority, paternity, and myth
  topic map 2026-07-06 · moc, backpropagation, history-of-ml, linnainmaa, automatic-differentiation
• Is "training-vs-inference compute asymmetry" the missing bridge note between the vault's two biggest clusters?
  question answered 2026-07-06 · gap-detection, missing-bridge, inference, backpropagation, compute-economics
• Does Griewank (2012) "Who Invented the Reverse Mode of Differentiation?" mention or discuss Shun'ichi Amari as a priority claimant?
  capture promoted 2026-07-05 · griewank, amari, backpropagation, reverse-mode, automatic-differentiation
• Did Rumelhart, Hinton & Williams (1986) explicitly invoke random initial weights as a symmetry-breaking mechanism in the Nature paper or their own writings?
  capture promoted 2026-07-05 · backpropagation, rumelhart-hinton-williams-1986, symmetry-breaking, weight-initialization, history-of-ai
• Did Ivakhnenko (1965 GMDH) and Amari (1967 SGD MLP) develop deep-network training methods that Rumelhart-Hinton-Williams 1986 failed to cite?
  capture promoted 2026-07-05 · backpropagation, rumelhart-hinton-williams-1986, ivakhnenko, gmdh, amari
• Who was David Parker, and what exactly did his 1985 independent rediscovery of backpropagation consist of — paper, report, or preprint?
  capture promoted 2026-07-05 · backpropagation, david-parker, learning-logic, independent-discovery, history-of-ai
• Do the 1986 Rumelhart-Hinton-Williams Nature paper's actual demonstrations of "useful internal representations" include a two-hidden-unit mirror-symmetry network and a five-layer family-tree network, as claimed by chsasank.com?
  capture promoted 2026-07-04 · backpropagation, rumelhart-hinton-williams-1986, multilayer-perceptron, internal-representations, history-of-ai
• Did Robbins & Monro (1951) originate stochastic gradient descent, and is Schmidhuber correct that Amari applied this specific method to MLPs in 1967?
  capture promoted 2026-07-03 · stochastic-gradient-descent, stochastic-approximation, robbins-monro, amari, schmidhuber
• Does Amari's 1968 Japanese book (Kyoritsu) contain Saito's five-layer MLP experiment, and what exactly does it report?
  capture promoted 2026-07-03 · amari, saito, schmidhuber, multilayer-perceptron, stochastic-gradient-descent
• Did Kunihiko Fukushima's 1979 Neocognitron constitute the first multilayer convolutional neural network, and what do primary sources actually claim?
  capture promoted 2026-07-03 · fukushima, neocognitron, convolutional-neural-network, cnn, deep-learning
• Capture: Does Table 5 in Griewank 2014 independently support a Tier-1 claim about Linnainmaa's backward pass?
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-01 · automatic-differentiation, linnainmaa, griewank, backpropagation, reverse-mode
• Capture: What Griewank 2012 says about Linnainmaa's priority in autodiff, and how that work was received before the 2010s
  capture promoted 2026-07-01 · automatic-differentiation, linnainmaa, griewank, backpropagation, reverse-mode
• Does Schmidhuber arXiv:2005.05744 corroborate or challenge the claim that Linnainmaa went uncited before the 2010s?
  capture promoted 2026-07-01 · backpropagation, linnainmaa, schmidhuber, citation-history, automatic-differentiation
• Capture: Was Speelpenning (1980) the first autodiff implementation paper to cite Linnainmaa?
  capture promoted 2026-07-01 · automatic-differentiation, linnainmaa, speelpenning, backpropagation, reverse-mode
• What is the vanishing gradient problem and which paper first characterized it rigorously?
  capture promoted 2026-07-01 · deep-learning, backpropagation, training-dynamics, neural-networks, history-of-ml
• Does Baydin et al. (2018) JMLR survey explicitly discuss Linnainmaa's citation history?
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-01 · automatic-differentiation, backpropagation, linnainmaa, citation-history, historiography-of-ml
• Did Schmidhuber's "Who Invented Backpropagation?" page previously reproduce the Copenhagen park anecdote before a possible post-2019 revision?
  note promoted Tier 1 2026-07-01 · backpropagation, schmidhuber, linnainmaa, griewank, historiography-of-ml
• Capture: Is Linnainmaa's 1976 paper locatable/accessible, and does it describe reverse-mode autodiff? (with a venue correction)
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-01 · automatic-differentiation, linnainmaa, reverse-mode, backpropagation, history-of-ml
• What Hinton meant by calling backpropagation biologically implausible
  capture promoted 2026-06-30 · backpropagation, biological-plausibility, geoffrey-hinton, forward-forward, credit-assignment
• Kelley (1960) and Bryson (1961) in the backpropagation lineage
  capture promoted 2026-06-30 · backpropagation, optimal-control, history-of-AI, gradient-descent, chain-rule
• Credit Assignment Problem (Minsky 1961) and Backpropagation
  capture promoted 2026-06-30 · backpropagation, credit-assignment, minsky, rumelhart-hinton-williams, neural-networks
• Who first applied backpropagation to a practical recognition task, and when
  capture promoted 2026-06-30 · backpropagation, neural-networks, LeCun, deep-learning-history, handwritten-digit-recognition
• Why neural-network research stalled between the 1969 Perceptrons book and the mid-1980s revival
  capture promoted 2026-06-30 · neural-networks, ai-history, ai-winter, backpropagation, perceptrons
• Did Shun'ichi Amari describe a form of gradient descent for layered networks in the 1960s?
  capture promoted 2026-06-29 · amari, backpropagation, gradient-descent, stochastic-gradient-descent, multilayer-perceptron
• Capture: What did the 1986 Rumelhart, Hinton & Williams Nature paper add that earlier formulations did not?
  capture promoted Tier 2 2026-06-29 · backpropagation, rumelhart, hinton, williams, history-of-ml
• Capture: What is the reverse-mode automatic differentiation / backpropagation correspondence, stated precisely?
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-06-29 · automatic-differentiation, reverse-mode-ad, backpropagation, chain-rule, computational-graph
• Capture: Who was Paul Werbos, and what did his 1974 Harvard PhD thesis actually claim about backpropagation?
  capture promoted Tier 2 2026-06-29 · werbos, backpropagation, history-of-ml, freud, harvard
• Citation data for Linnainmaa 1970/1976: verifying the 'essentially uncited before the 2010s' claim
  capture promoted 2026-06-28 · backpropagation, automatic-differentiation, Linnainmaa, citation-history, history-of-AI
• Capture: Griewank 2012 — backward-pass description of Linnainmaa's algorithm and Copenhagen park anecdote
  capture promoted 2026-06-28 · automatic-differentiation, linnainmaa, griewank, backpropagation, reverse-mode
• Linnainmaa's 1970 thesis was a contribution to numerical analysis, not artificial intelligence
  claim budding Tier 2 2026-06-26 · linnainmaa, numerical-analysis, automatic-differentiation, history-of-computation, backpropagation
• Linnainmaa has priority over reverse-mode automatic differentiation but not paternity — his work had no traceable causal influence on backpropagation's adoption in AI
  claim budding Tier 4 2026-06-26 · linnainmaa, backpropagation, history-of-computation, automatic-differentiation, reverse-mode-ad
• Linnainmaa's algorithm computes all rounding-error sensitivities in a single backward pass — the structure now called reverse-mode automatic differentiation
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-06-26 · linnainmaa, reverse-mode-ad, automatic-differentiation, numerical-analysis, rounding-error
• Pull citation data for Linnainmaa 1970/1976 to verify the claim that the work was essentially uncited before the 2010s
  question open 2026-06-26 · linnainmaa, backpropagation, citation-analysis, verification, history-of-computation
• the floating-point thesis
  note published 2026-06-26 · linnainmaa, backpropagation, numerical-analysis, automatic-differentiation, history-of-computation
• The backpropagation gap — outer trace, inner path, no biological analog
  claim seedling 2026-05-31 · backpropagation, introspection, learning-mechanism, brain, outer-trace