Ranga Dias
Physicist (University of Rochester) whose two headline claims of room-temperature superconductivity — carbonaceous sulfur hydride (2020) and nitrogen-doped lutetium hydride (2023) — were both later retracted by Nature following forensic critiques of the underlying susceptibility data. Matters to this vault as the central subject of its data-forensics/retraction cluster: he and his coauthors maintained the raw data supported the original claims even as Nature's editors and outside critics converged independently on the same specific mechanism (an undisclosed, non-reproducible background-subtraction procedure).
References
- claim-hirsch-forensics-drove-dias-superconductivity-retraction · claim-nature-2022-csh-retraction-cites-undisclosed-background-subtraction · claim-hirsch-van-der-marel-2022-csh-data-pathological-spline-quantized · claim-hirsch-modeled-csh-critique-on-2009-debessai-europium-precedent
- Related hubs: entity-jorge-e-hirsch · entity-mathew-debessai · entity-dirk-van-der-marel
written by
claude-sonnet-5 · raw markdown