Gersick's 1991 synthesis turns the punctuated-equilibrium borrowing into an explicit six-field structural-comparison method resting on two stated premises, and names each transplanted construct's donor
Where the 1988 paper borrowed the term once, with a one-paragraph justification (claim-gersick-1988-names-eldredge-gould-as-reasoned-structural-analogy), Gersick's 1991 Academy of Management Review synthesis, "Revolutionary Change Theories: A Multilevel Exploration of the Punctuated Equilibrium Paradigm," escalates the analogy into a stated research method. She names the biological source directly (p. 11): "Natural historians Niles Eldredge and Stephen Gould (1972) postulate a very different view of evolution as punctuated equilibrium. They propose that lineages exist in essentially static form (equilibrium) over most of their histories, and new species arise abruptly, through sudden, revolutionary 'punctuations' of rapid change."
The governing method is stated plainly (p. 12): "My argument that models from different fields have much to offer each other begins with the premise that they reflect common processes. Each theory examined here centers on the same paradigm, or basic gestalt, of evolution." Two explicit premises underlie the paper (p. 11): that there are important commonalities in how many systems, including human systems, change; and that comparing findings from disparate areas is valuable because different facets of kindred processes come into focus as level of analysis varies. Eldredge & Gould's biology is then one of six domains set side by side in comparison tables — individual adult development, group development, organizational evolution, history of science, biological evolution, and self-organizing systems — each quoted in the theorists' own words to document a shared deep structure / equilibrium / revolution structure.
The same source-naming discipline recurs one construct later: Gersick imports her central term "deep structure" from a second, unrelated field by name — "I use the term deep structure (Chomsky, 1966) for its general appropriateness" (p. 13). Her working method across both papers is to name a donor field and donor author for each transplanted construct and then argue for the structural fit, rather than using borrowed vocabulary unattributed.
This note states the 1991 paper's comparative method and its attribution discipline; the mechanism of the deep-structure cycle itself is claim-gersick-1991-punctuated-equilibrium-deep-structure, with its verbatim confirmation at claim-gersick-1991-deep-structure-quotes-confirmed-verbatim. The 1991 paper is also the vault's hinge into the Tushman/Romanelli reorientation literature (claim-gersick-1991-attributes-3x-figure-to-tushman-newman-romanelli-1986). See moc-schema-change-and-restructuring.
Source
“Natural historians Niles Eldredge and Stephen Gould (1972) postulate a very different view of evolution as punctuated equilibrium. They propose that lineages exist in essentially static form (equilibrium) over most of their histories, and new species arise abruptly, through sudden, revolutionary "punctuations" of rapid change”
claude-opus-4-8 · Promotion from 10-inbox/raw/2026-11-05-who-was-connie-gersick-and-did-her-19881991.md, 2026-11-21 · raw markdown