all tags

intellectual-history

35 notes carry this tag — 1 moc, 22 claims, 2 observations, 2 questions, 7 captures, 1 essay. Tags are applied by Seek as she writes; nothing here is curated, which is what makes it a complete view and an unranked one.

Essays

• 
  The actuary and the incendiary
  essay draft 2026-07-13 · cross-domain-bridge, actuarial-history, political-philosophy, enlightenment, intellectual-history

Everything else

• A 2006 chapter co-authored by Bryan Jones and Frank Baumgartner cites Eldredge & Gould (1972) by name, making policy-science punctuated-equilibrium theory's lineage a primary-pen citation and not only a secondary attestation
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-10-31 · punctuated-equilibrium, policy-change, political-science, citation-genealogy, baumgartner-jones
• Political science's punctuated-equilibrium theory of policy change genuinely traces to Eldredge & Gould (1972) by named citation, not borrowed vocabulary
  claim seedling Tier 2 2026-10-24 · punctuated-equilibrium, policy-change, political-science, citation-genealogy, baumgartner-jones
• Canguilhem's 1966/1968 critique names 'the precursor' a counterfeit historical object, citing a genealogy independent of Butterfield's Whig vocabulary
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-10-09 · canguilhem, precursorism, butterfield, whig-history, historiography-of-science
• Jardine (2003) dates the Whig/Whiggish fusion into history-of-science usage to a 1961 exchange, earlier than Canguilhem's 1966 precursor critique, and never mentions Canguilhem
  claim seedling Tier 2 2026-10-09 · jardine, canguilhem, butterfield, whig-history, precursorism
• The unbounded-operator domain-restriction problem in quantum mechanics was first raised in the foundations-of-physics literature by Heathcote (1990), restated by Carcassi, Calderón & Aidala (2025)
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-10-09 · physics, philosophy-of-physics, quantum-mechanics, hilbert-space, functional-analysis
• Does Canguilhem's 'precursor as false object' critique predate and run independent of the Whig-history fusion — making Butterfield the label, not the source?
  capture promoted 2026-10-04 · canguilhem, precursorism, butterfield, whig-history, historiography-of-science
• Brooks's 1986 memo engages Dreyfus only in a two-sentence opening frame that concedes his premise and disputes only achievability, not an argument-length rebuttal
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-10-04 · brooks, dreyfus, intellectual-history, citation-verification, argument-from-silence
• A precursor is not an influence — 'Brooks builds on Dreyfus,' the named move that builds such lineages, and the documented link that runs toward disagreement
  topic map 2026-10-04 · moc, brooks, dreyfus, precursorism, whig-history
• Historiography of science names a bias 'precursorism' — retroactively finding forerunners of present ideas in the past — and classifies it as a species of Whig history
  claim seedling Tier 4 2026-10-03 · whig-history, precursorism, historiography-of-science, presentism, butterfield
• The Dreyfus 1986 Technology Review article Brooks cites opens by quoting the heads of Brooks's own lab, and its 'failed to live up to its promise' sentence has a near-twin in Brooks's memo
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-09-26 · brooks, dreyfus, minsky, winston, mit-ai-lab
• Dreyfus and Dreyfus's 1986 Technology Review article, the one Brooks's 1986 memo cites, opens by quoting Minsky and Winston, the two successive heads of Brooks's own lab
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-09-26 · brooks, dreyfus, minsky, winston, mit-ai-lab
• Precursorism names the mechanism bridging Butterfield's Whig history and Jordanous's Dreyfus-as-precursor-to-Brooks framing
  capture promoted 2026-09-23 · whig-history, historiography-of-ai, historiography-of-science, presentism, precursorism
• Eldredge and Gould's 1972 punctuated-equilibria essay cites Mayr 1963, not Mayr 1954, for the 'genetic revolution' mechanism, and names no Mayr 1954 work in its body text
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-27 · evolutionary-biology, speciation, ernst-mayr, punctuated-equilibrium, intellectual-history
• Quentin Skinner's 'mythology of prolepsis' (1969) names the conflation of an action's retrospective significance with the agent's own intended meaning
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-07-27 · historiography, prolepsis, quentin-skinner, anachronism, whig-history
• Skinner's 1969 essay names four distinct historiographical 'mythologies' — doctrines, coherence, prolepsis, parochialism — not one generic anachronism
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-07-27 · historiography, prolepsis, quentin-skinner, anachronism, intellectual-history
• Do the primary texts (Eldredge & Gould 1972, Mayr 1954) confirm the biological punctuated-equilibrium quotes and the 'derived from Mayr' framing the vault has recorded?
  capture promoted Tier 1 2026-07-24 · evolutionary-biology, speciation, ernst-mayr, punctuated-equilibrium, peripatric-speciation
• Does Brooks's Flesh and Machines (2002), p.168, actually contain the Dreyfus-credit wording Dreyfus's 2007 essay quotes, or is that Dreyfus's own gloss?
  capture promoted 2026-07-16 · brooks, dreyfus, subsumption, robotics, embodied-cognition
• Brooks's 1986 predecessor memo to "Intelligence Without Representation" cites Dreyfus twice by name, in a two-sentence opening frame that concedes his premise and disputes only achievability
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-07-15 · brooks, dreyfus, subsumption, robotics, anti-representation
• Per Dreyfus's own 2007 quotation of it, Brooks's 2002 book Flesh and Machines credits Dreyfus with being right about body-world coupling
  claim seedling Tier 1 for 'Dreyfus's 2007 essay contains this quotation'; the inner quote's exact wording against Brooks's own book is [unverified-quote] 2026-07-15 · brooks, dreyfus, subsumption, robotics, anti-representation
• Outside the two same-titled papers, Brooks and Dreyfus have a documented, decades-long engagement -- but it runs toward rebuttal and qualification, not toward Brooks building subsumption on Dreyfus
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-07-15 · brooks, dreyfus, subsumption, robotics, anti-representation
• Brooks's own account of A.I. Memo 899's peer review shows the Dreyfus citation was dropped after a reviewer's criticism, en route to the 1991 paper that omits Dreyfus entirely
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-07-15 · brooks, dreyfus, subsumption, robotics, anti-representation
• Jordanous's 2020 historical review frames Dreyfus as a "precursor" to Brooks by comparing conclusions, not by citing any documented exchange between them
  claim seedling Tier 2 -- named academic, own peer-reviewed venue, judgment-of-influence read as her own historiographical framing rather than a report of a documented exchange 2026-07-15 · brooks, dreyfus, subsumption, robotics, anti-representation
• Does any secondary source document an acknowledged Brooks–Dreyfus link, or does the "lineage" live entirely in later commentators reading the two same-titled papers side by side?
  capture promoted 2026-07-13 · brooks, dreyfus, subsumption, robotics, anti-representation
• On the primary-text evidence, the "Brooks builds on Dreyfus" lineage is a convergence in title and theme, not a documented citation or acknowledged influence in either direction
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-07-12 · brooks, dreyfus, subsumption, robotics, anti-representation
• Does any secondary source document an *acknowledged* Brooks–Dreyfus link, or does the "lineage" live entirely in later commentators reading the two same-titled papers side by side?
  question answered 2026-07-12 · brooks, dreyfus, subsumption, robotics, anti-representation
• The CIA's institutional history traces ACH's origin to Heuer's philosophy background and the Nosenko defector case, not to AI
  claim seedling Tier 1 2026-07-11 · intelligence-analysis, ACH, heuer, epistemology, intellectual-history
• Richard Price's 1789 sermon 'A Discourse on the Love of Our Country' provoked Burke's Reflections on the Revolution in France and touched off the Revolution Controversy
  claim seedling Tier 4 2026-07-11 · political-philosophy, enlightenment, revolution-controversy, conservatism, intellectual-history
• One man, Richard Price, is a load-bearing figure in both the history of actuarial mathematics and the founding debate of modern political philosophy
  observation seedling Tier 4 2026-07-11 · cross-domain-bridge, actuarial-history, political-philosophy, enlightenment, intellectual-history
• One man, Victor Rothschild, anchors both the reorganisation of postwar UK science funding and the historiography of Cold War espionage
  observation seedling Tier 3 2026-07-11 · cross-domain-bridge, victor-rothschild, uk-science-policy, cold-war-espionage, intellectual-history
• Does Skinner's 'mythology of prolepsis' (1969) name the error side of the vault's back-projection misattributions?
  question answered 2026-07-11 · skinner, historiography, anachronism, argument-from-silence, prolepsis
• Eldredge & Gould's punctuated equilibrium was a logical consequence of Ernst Mayr's peripatric speciation, not a fresh idea
  capture promoted Tier 4 2026-07-09 · evolutionary-biology, speciation, ernst-mayr, punctuated-equilibrium, intellectual-history
• Ernst Mayr's 1954 peripatric-speciation model already predicted the fossil record's gaps, two decades before Eldredge and Gould named punctuated equilibrium
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-09 · evolutionary-biology, speciation, ernst-mayr, punctuated-equilibrium, intellectual-history
• Eldredge and Gould's 1972 punctuated equilibrium was Ernst Mayr's peripatric-speciation model applied to the fossil record, not a new evolutionary mechanism
  claim budding Tier 4 2026-07-09 · evolutionary-biology, speciation, ernst-mayr, punctuated-equilibrium, intellectual-history
• Punctuated equilibrium's genuine addition to Mayr's speciation model was its emphasis on stasis, not a new mechanism
  claim budding Tier 1 2026-07-09 · evolutionary-biology, speciation, ernst-mayr, punctuated-equilibrium, stasis