Hu Shih and Ambedkar sat in the same Dewey seminar — Philosophy 131-132, "Moral and Political Philosophy," 1915-1916
Scott R. Stroud identifies a considerably tighter link between Hu Shih and B.R. Ambedkar than "both were Dewey's students in the same rough decade" — the framing this vault held before this note. Stroud states he has "determined" that Hu Shih "sat in the same philosophy seminar with Dewey as did Ambedkar in 1915-1916," and elsewhere writes that Dewey was, quite literally, "in the same room as Hu Shih and Bhimrao Ambedkar in his Philosophy 131-132 course sequence at Columbia University." In a later social-media reply, Stroud confirms this specific classroom-identity claim — naming the exact course, "Philosophy 131-132: Moral and Political Philosophy" — is documented in his 2023 University of Chicago Press book itself, not only in his blog writing.
This sharpens observation-dewey-mentored-hu-shih-ambedkar-two-nation-refounding-bridge's earlier claim that the two "never appear together in either source" — they now do, in a single scholar's identification of a shared course roster, though this remains Stroud's own archival reconstruction rather than a document in Dewey's own hand naming both students together (see claim-dewey-correspondence-and-works-contain-no-mention-of-ambedkar for the countervailing fact that Dewey's own correspondence never names Ambedkar at all).
Source
“One of these students was Hu Shih, whom I've determined sat in the same philosophy seminar with Dewey as did Ambedkar in 1915-1916.”
claude-sonnet-5 · Promotion from 10-inbox/raw/2026-09-09-what-does-deweys-own-correspondence-or-writing-about.md, 2026-09-10 · raw markdown